Saxophones Used YAS-32 PL is this normal cosmetic wear?

Messages
72
Location
Barnstaple
Dear All,

I've been picking @Stephen Howard and @DavidUK ,@Colin the Bear 's brains when deciding between alto saxophones. Finally, my old new YAS-32 PL has arrived from a reputable saxophone dealer. The lacquer condition has been described as very good but I'm not quite sure if reality matches up with this. (worried about red rot spots or if this is just usual green corrosion). The pads look ok to the untrained eye. Also, I found the 4c mouthpiece and more than much used condition. I was hoping for some input on the pictures I attach to hopefully alleviate my worries.

As a second note, I've been playing my friends JP tenor basic saxophone and have after 2 months not much trouble playing notes and holding the pitch of long notes (within expectation) and playing some scales / songs. The notes also don't accidentally vibrate. On the YAS-32 I find everything very much harder and anything from low e downwards tends to have an "auto-vibrato" function..... for want of a better way to describe it.

Thanks for your input and helping me at the beginning of my saxophone journey.

All the best,

Doc_C

IMG_9818.webp

IMG_9824.webp
 

Attachments

  • IMG_9817.webp
    IMG_9817.webp
    43.5 KB · : 169
Can't remember how much you paid, or where you bought it? Can you advise, and maybe link to your original thread/posts please.

It's an old one for sure. Pads aren't original so they may be OK as you say. The few red spots could be polished back to brass if you're worried, but they'll return in time.

If you paid £400 it's a good buy. If you paid £1,000 it may be a poor one, cosmetically.
The auto-vibrato suggests a leak which suggests poor maintenance, which suggests a few hundred pounds or more service bill coming your way.

@Stephen Howard will disagree with me shortly... 😉
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Put a leak light down it.
Is the vibrate thing "motorboating"?
That may be mouthpiece position or a leak.
A new 4c or 5c will cost £30 to 40.
Any saxophone will need regulating. If it's beyond you, you'll need a tech.
Does the Nippon label mean it's a Japanese market horn?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Finish looks darn near new. Close to new condition.

Pads and corks probably need some attention. That's normal.

My main alto hasn't had any finish on most of it for 30 years now, it's mostly red. Plays fantastic. The condition of the finish has nothing to do with the playing qualities of the instrument. Trying to polish off little spots on a lacquered brass instrument is nothing but a colossal waste of time.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
For such an old horn it looks to be in pretty good nick. Clearly needs a service though - or at least a proper tweak.
Regarding the finish: sounds reassuring. I was a bit "shocked" at first but that's me not having seen many saxes over the years. Especially the inside was an initial OMG moment. I had visions of it rotting away any moment plus coupled with what @DavidUK

I had a bit more of a dabble and I can get a low Bb out. Depending on the way I adjust embouchure and blowing strengths I can make the vibrato go away for a moment.

regarding needing a service: I paid 890 sterling for it from thesaxshack who states all horns are serviced and set up. I'm a bit disappointed if it needs a service after a service. Especially, since he seems to be established and get's good word of mouth online. Anyone the forum can recommend in the Devon area? Or should I just post it to @Stephen Howard Howard ? Or should I return it and go on the hunt again / hope that @DavidUK sources something suitable and passes it on here?

thanks everyone for taking the time. should we ever meet in person I'll buy the beers / coffees.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Regarding the finish: sounds reassuring. I was a bit "shocked" at first but that's me not having seen many saxes over the years. Especially the inside was an initial OMG moment. I had visions of it rotting away any moment plus coupled with what @DavidUK

I had a bit more of a dabble and I can get a low Bb out. Depending on the way I adjust embouchure and blowing strengths I can make the vibrato go away for a moment.

regarding needing a service: I paid 890 sterling for it from thesaxshack who states all horns are serviced and set up. I'm a bit disappointed if it needs a service after a service. Especially, since he seems to be established and get's good word of mouth online. Anyone the forum can recommend in the Devon area? Or should I just post it to @Stephen Howard Howard ? Or should I return it and go on the hunt again / hope that @DavidUK sources something suitable and passes it on here?

thanks everyone for taking the time. should we ever meet in person I'll buy the beers / coffees.
You could try contacting @griff136 in Exmouth, I'm sure he won't mind checking it over for you and giving you an honest assessment: if it needs extra work maybe have a chat with the saxshack about contributing towards any additional work?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
To be honest, @Dr.cox I think you may be overthinking this one a bit. I think the condition is fine for a used sax. In my view, saxes are to be played rather than examined close up. A few cosmetic blemishes don't matter much. All my saxes have areas of wear, and one of them (an old Yanagisawa alto) has been through the wars a bit, and it looks pretty scruffy. It plays great. Incidentally, Yamahas of this generation have a bit of a reputation for scratched lacquer on the side of the bell, where the sax rubs agains the player. This one doesn't seem to have any of that.

I'd also be pretty surprised if it needed much work. You've bought a sax from Stoke, and had it shipped to lovely Devon. Any sax which is shipped can need a tweak, due to couriers not handling parcels with the care we all would. This can apply to a brand new, £9k sax as much as a used one. You might get away with it, but maybe not. Whenever I sell a sax, if it's shipped, I advise the buyer of this. Sax Shack has a good reputation, so I'd guess the sax was properly checked over. (I have no connection with them whatsoever).

Personally, I'd get it checked over, make sure it's playing well and then just enjoy playing it. It's a good sax.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I was about to ask if it had been shipped. I missed that point.

As @jonf says, courriers are often 'brutal' and don't give a damn about whatever 'FRAGILE' notice on parcels.

I have received saxes from trusted members of the forum that needed a bit of attention after shipping. It's only just normal.

Also, cosmetic imperfections like those pictured look quite normal for a sax of a certain age. I bought a soprano a few years ago that has similar spots and plays great several years later. I only did a minor service, myself, to reset a few pads and it's been fine ever since.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I suddenly realize that the vibrato you describe may be related to a minor issue with the G# key. When you close the keys to play D, E or F, with your right hand, check if the G# key is fully closed and doesn't move if you try to lift it.

There is a small screw on the arm that extends backward from the F key over the G# key.

IMG_20230408_174355130~2.webp


If it's not set properly, it allows the G# key to vibrate and ... you know what.

I've had this in the past. It can be sorted in a matter of seconds, if that's it.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom