Theory & Impro Transposition...I can't stand the rain

eb424

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,216
Location
london
Hi sorry having a moment (again)..lol..The backing track is g my music is in g. I have taken it up 2 and an octave...I now have 2 sharps C and F which i think puts me in D..the next one round on the circle of fifths..shouldn't i be in A...Aaarghh one day sink in it shall..
 
For tenor you transpose G up a whole tone to A (ie you add 2 sharps to the existing 1 sharp)

For alto you transpose up a major 6 to E (ie add three sharps to the existing one sharp)
 
You misinterpreted what you read. That rule is correct for accidentals, NOT for key signatures. The sharps and flats in the key signature apply to ALL octaves. The shaps/flats/naturals in accidentals apply only to the octave they're written in for the duration of the bar.

Do you know what I mean by an accidental?
 
I'll assume you're talking about the first few bars:

1681238543298.png


Those are all F naturals, which transpose to G naturals for you. The natural sign applies to every F on that space in the measure.

All the letter note names you penciled in are correct except for the very last bar.
 
I'll assume you're talking about the first few bars:

View attachment 22814

Those are all F naturals, which transpose to G naturals for you. The natural sign applies to every F on that space in the measure.

All the letter note names you penciled in are correct except for the very last bar.
I was talking the 6th bar above "pane" but i guess it's the same..thought all the f naturals were accidentals because F natural isn't in A major..???..thanks as usual...shame I don't live in the states..lol
 
You got it! I was thinking it's a shame I don't live in the UK... LOL. There's a whole lot of crazy over here.
Not so different here tbf...seriously thanks I wasn't after a free lesson, just wondered why i'd marked it up as D major..it's a real challenge on your own, but hey once ive learnt my 20 songs so as i can play the care home.. I'll learn to read music properly..thanks again..
 
No idea what made you think D other than mixing up the circle of 5ths with the transposition rules.

Just try to remember tenor reads 1 whole step (aka 2 half steps) above concert pitch. Usually going up to the next letter note will get you there, i.e., G (concert) to A (tenor sax).

If/when you get that alto, the rule is alto reads 1-1/2 steps below concert pitch, i.e., G concert to E (alto sax).

When I transpose, I imagine walking up/down the chromatic scale on my horn, so for the alto example, I finger in the air (or on my horn) from G - F#(1), F(2), E(3 half steps).

For tenor from G - G#(1), A(2 half steps). After doing that a lot, you'll eventually know the answer instantly without counting half steps.

I rarely recommend this, but in your case, switching to a C melody sax would alleviate most of your frustrations since there would never be any transposition to deal with. That seems to be your biggest hurdle by far.
 
Hi sorry having a moment (again)..lol..The backing track is g my music is in g. I have taken it up 2 and an octave...I now have 2 sharps C and F which i think puts me in D..the next one round on the circle of fifths..shouldn't i be in A...Aaarghh one day sink in it shall..
So you basically got it right, except for the “I now have 2 sharps” part. It should be in A - which is 3 sharps (F#-C#-G#).

Maybe you got the “2 sharps” part because in this song, it seems most of the written F#’s (G# on tenor) are changed to F natural (tenor, G natural). This would leave you with C# and F# in the melody notes, and no G#. Hence the confusion.

Do you have a circle of fifths diagram to refer to? I like this one, from Wikipedia
1681244711435.webp


If your sheet music is in G, find that on the circle, then go clockwise two places for tenor, which gets you to A. (For alto. you go three places, to E). You then have to go up two semitones (plus an octave) on tenor for each note. (Alto, up a major sixth, or down a minor third.)
 
No idea what made you think D other than mixing up the circle of 5ths with the transposition rules.

Just try to remember tenor reads 1 whole step (aka 2 half steps) above concert pitch. Usually going up to the next letter note will get you there, i.e., G (concert) to A (tenor sax).

If/when you get that alto, the rule is alto reads 1-1/2 steps below concert pitch, i.e., G concert to E (alto sax).

When I transpose, I imagine walking up/down the chromatic scale on my horn, so for the alto example, I finger in the air (or on my horn) from G - F#(1), F(2), E(3 half steps).

For tenor from G - G#(1), A(2 half steps). After doing that a lot, you'll eventually know the answer instantly without counting half steps.

I rarely recommend this, but in your case, switching to a C melody sax would alleviate most of your frustrations since there would never be any transposition to deal with. That seems to be your biggest hurdle by far.
Hey @lydian sorry about the late reply quite ungrateful of me aftervall you help but had to leave sax practice and pop indoors...I thought D major as i only had 2 sharps as all the Fs were low so I made them natural. Nice tip re the alto I bought a cheap one so will defo use the advice . No chancevwith the c melody im not a quiter..lol. you may not believe it but I have transposed about 30 songs most with no problem .I just get stuck with my limitations at some points..at least i recognised with this one that I should have been in A which made me question the missing G#s..slowly slowly. Thanks again for the help and guidance..
 
So you basically got it right, except for the “I now have 2 sharps” part. It should be in A - which is 3 sharps (F#-C#-G#).

Maybe you got the “2 sharps” part because in this song, it seems most of the written F#’s (G# on tenor) are changed to F natural (tenor, G natural). This would leave you with C# and F# in the melody notes, and no G#. Hence the confusion.

Do you have a circle of fifths diagram to refer to? I like this one, from Wikipedia
View attachment 22815

If your sheet music is in G, find that on the circle, then go clockwise two places for tenor, which gets you to A. (For alto. you go three places, to E). You then have to go up two semitones (plus an octave) on tenor for each note. (Alto, up a major sixth, or down a minor third.)
That was it. I had no G#s in the whole song so thought I hadctransposed to D an confysion..I havent really looked at the flat side of the circle but made up the saying Cool Gorillas Do Aerobics Evenings Bare ( for) Fun to rememer the keys and use Fat cats Go Down Alleys Chasing Birds to to remember the sharps..working on the flat side in my head..lol think it worksnout the same acronym with Battle Ends And Down Goes Charles Father...not done much flat transposition tho tbf..and thanks for the pointers..
 
I learned the key signatures as a kid (I had them all down by the age of 12), and I’m 75 now, so you can probably find the circle of fifths on any xray of any part of my body.

I always remember the Bb and Eb transpositions as “Add two sharps”(Bb) and “Add three sharps” (Eb). And “Add a sharp” is the same as “Subtract a flat”. So the transposition for alto from the key of Bb is “Subtract 2 flats and add 1 sharp” - that is, the key of G on alto.

When I used to do a lot of casuals/club dates (not sure what they are called in your neck of the woods), the leaders used to call tunes and keys by naming the tune and holding the number of sharps or flats in their fingers. Flats down and sharps up. So “There Will Never Be Another You” in Eb would be called by “Sheepherders’ Lament” and 3 fingers down.
 
Ok so i read somewhere that the key signature only relate to that note...i.e. # on the top line only means middle F is sharp ( F2?) not the bottom F, is that wrong ?
It is actually quite a fundamental concept. I think you said you have a teacher? This is something they should have told you.

Anyway the sharps and flats in a key signature as lydian says apply to all of those notes in all octaves. Think about when you play a G scale over two octaves. You don't play one F sharp and the other natural (I hope!)

Do you know what I mean by an accidental?
Sort of but they do confuse me a bit..I know its a natural sign and thought it turned the note back from whatever it was before for the duration of the bar..

An accidental can be
♭, ♮ or # (not just natural) It applies to that one note for the duration of the bar unless it is cancelled by another accidental.

If you are in C there may be a bar with an F that is made into F# by using the # accidental.
 
Last edited:
That was it. I had no G#s in the whole song so thought I hadctransposed to D an confysion..I havent really looked at the flat side of the circle but made up the saying Cool Gorillas Do Aerobics Evenings Bare ( for) Fun to rememer the keys and use Fat cats Go Down Alleys Chasing Birds to to remember the sharps..working on the flat side in my head..lol think it worksnout the same acronym with Battle Ends And Down Goes Charles Father...not done much flat transposition tho tbf..and thanks for the pointers..
Just to be pedantic and add my two pennyworth your acronym is slightly off as your "Fat Cats" will end up having two C#. your flat's acronym is the one I know and use the most. It can simply be reversed for the Sharps "Father Charles Goes Down And Ends Battle"
 
Just to be pedantic and add my two pennyworth your acronym is slightly off as your "Fat Cats" will end up having two C#. your flat's acronym is the one I know and use the most. It can simply be reversed for the Sharps "Father Charles Goes Down And ends battle

Just to be pedantic and add my two pennyworth your acronym is slightly off as your "Fat Cats" will end up having two C#. your flat's acronym is the one I know and use the most. It can simply be reversed for the Sharps "Father Charles Goes Down And Ends Battle"
Typical that one was out a book..mine was the gorillas...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,577
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom