Flutes etc. Tin whistles - the perfect GAS instrument?

[mizmar]

Wexford Carol for Christmas and it's scored in E.

Tony Dixon DX107A - A Maj whistle

So it turns out that this fits exactly with the score; and follows the fingering I found here in D for the D whistle...
... I don't seem to able to count well enough to work out why. Anyone

Otherwise; it's mellow like the low D but doesn't need the pipers grip and doesn't get as resistant at the top. So that's nice.

 

[Dr G]

So it turns out that this fits exactly with the score; and follows the fingering I found here in D for the D whistle...
... I don't seem to able to count well enough to work out why. Anyone

Otherwise; it's mellow like the low D but doesn't need the pipers grip and doesn't get as resistant at the top. So that's nice.

What’s your question? Which of those two scores are you trying to play?