This is really TL;DR. sorry.
Regarding the off-topic discussion in this thread regarding the effects of brass, weight, finish etc. of a saxophone on sound - a topic that pops up here and there...
I think it's worth pointing out that, although the analysis of Timbre is discussed in some places - such as the ratio of fundamental and overtones, or the distribution of partials etc. Discussion of what causes it is quite thin on the ground outside of heavy duty "The Physics of Musical Instruments" type texts. Why is it interesting? IMHO it's interesting because if things worked like the idealised soundwave in a tube of sites such as the NSW one, the resulting sound would be very boring. Timbre maketh the instrument.
I'd like to suggest (as a way of thinking about this) is what causes Tiber is energy leaking out from the fundamental to overtones and partials - little pockets of resonances getting fired up. And what allows that energy to leak out and flow around are imperfections - deviations from the perfect tube/cone. (the heavy duty books call this "nonlinear coupling", not really helpful to most people).
Examples:
Think of an open tone hole: it's not a nice sharp edge to low pressure; it's a real mess, round, three dimensional, a bit with a chimney and an obstacle above etc. Right there, it's impossible to generate a pure tone using the basic physics.
Think of the closed tone holes: these are not the perfectly hard, smooth surfaces of the ideal physics. Even with resonators, they're full of soft bits and edges. Worst case, they leak and the sound collapses or gets a pile of other frequencies. At best they allow energy to leak into partials.
Think of the Mouthpiece: this is a huge source of imperfections (couplings). Not only allowing energy to flow into all sorts of frequencies but, with the reed, giving the player more or less control of how that happens with the embouchure and choice of MP construction.
And then there's internal geometry....
Then the thing is, when thinking about stuff like surface finish, the mettle of the tube, weight etc. IMHO one really has to think about how or how much that factor can be allowing flow of energy between resonance / frequencies to affect the generated sound... and it is hard to think about these things.
Take the inside surface of the horn. There are two factors that affect sound; how well it reflects are molecules and laminar flow. The difference between leather of pads and brass is significant and well known. The difference between different aloies or lacquered is much less clear (give or take condensation, dirt etc). And a lot of the areas that are contentious (finish, weight etc.) are contentions (IMHO) because they are small differences that, anyway, contribute little (to energy flow between frequencies / resonances).
But clearly the most interesting thing is how we, the player, can direct energy around the available frequencies and resonances. And that we do that in response to what we hear - and even how it feels - is a very important nonlinear coupling! And almost impossible to take out of the system when a player compares equipment etc.
Regarding the off-topic discussion in this thread regarding the effects of brass, weight, finish etc. of a saxophone on sound - a topic that pops up here and there...
I think it's worth pointing out that, although the analysis of Timbre is discussed in some places - such as the ratio of fundamental and overtones, or the distribution of partials etc. Discussion of what causes it is quite thin on the ground outside of heavy duty "The Physics of Musical Instruments" type texts. Why is it interesting? IMHO it's interesting because if things worked like the idealised soundwave in a tube of sites such as the NSW one, the resulting sound would be very boring. Timbre maketh the instrument.
I'd like to suggest (as a way of thinking about this) is what causes Tiber is energy leaking out from the fundamental to overtones and partials - little pockets of resonances getting fired up. And what allows that energy to leak out and flow around are imperfections - deviations from the perfect tube/cone. (the heavy duty books call this "nonlinear coupling", not really helpful to most people).
Examples:
Think of an open tone hole: it's not a nice sharp edge to low pressure; it's a real mess, round, three dimensional, a bit with a chimney and an obstacle above etc. Right there, it's impossible to generate a pure tone using the basic physics.
Think of the closed tone holes: these are not the perfectly hard, smooth surfaces of the ideal physics. Even with resonators, they're full of soft bits and edges. Worst case, they leak and the sound collapses or gets a pile of other frequencies. At best they allow energy to leak into partials.
Think of the Mouthpiece: this is a huge source of imperfections (couplings). Not only allowing energy to flow into all sorts of frequencies but, with the reed, giving the player more or less control of how that happens with the embouchure and choice of MP construction.
And then there's internal geometry....
Then the thing is, when thinking about stuff like surface finish, the mettle of the tube, weight etc. IMHO one really has to think about how or how much that factor can be allowing flow of energy between resonance / frequencies to affect the generated sound... and it is hard to think about these things.
Take the inside surface of the horn. There are two factors that affect sound; how well it reflects are molecules and laminar flow. The difference between leather of pads and brass is significant and well known. The difference between different aloies or lacquered is much less clear (give or take condensation, dirt etc). And a lot of the areas that are contentious (finish, weight etc.) are contentions (IMHO) because they are small differences that, anyway, contribute little (to energy flow between frequencies / resonances).
But clearly the most interesting thing is how we, the player, can direct energy around the available frequencies and resonances. And that we do that in response to what we hear - and even how it feels - is a very important nonlinear coupling! And almost impossible to take out of the system when a player compares equipment etc.
