Playing the saxophone Things You Wished You'd Known Years Ago

Veggie Dave

Sax Worker
Messages
3,466
Location
Citizen of Nowhere
For me as an R&B/rock/pop sax player, it's that you don't need to blow your lungs out to be heard over the rest of an amplified band, or that you need a stupidly loud mouthpiece; you just need to be amplified (like everyone else is) and decent monitoring - something other musicians seem to have worked out decades ago. No one tells the singer to scream to be heard, so why do we tell each other to play louder, use louder, brighter mouthpieces? It makes no sense to play a mouthpiece you don't particularly like, that has a tone you don't want, at a volume you don't enjoy. No one else in the band is making these huge sacrifices to be heard, so why should we?

If there's a singer, there's a PA. Keep the set-up you like and use a mic instead. If it's a really loud environment (if it's not a jazz gig then aren't they all? 😉), get yourself some IEM (same price as a mouthpiece). Not only will it kill the volume, protecting your ears (I find much better than normal ear plugs), you get a perfect mix, too. The technology is 50 years old - even pub bands use them. There's no reason to struggle, no reason to compromise when there's a simple solution that will work in pretty much every situation you're ever likely to find yourself in.
 
For me as an R&B/rock/pop sax player, it's that you don't need to blow your lungs out to be heard over the rest of an amplified band, or that you need a stupidly loud mouthpiece; you just need to be amplified (like everyone else is) and decent monitoring - something other musicians seem to have worked out decades ago. No one tells the singer to scream to be heard, so why do we tell each other to play louder, use louder, brighter mouthpieces? It makes no sense to play a mouthpiece you don't particularly like, that has a tone you don't want, at a volume you don't enjoy. No one else in the band is making these huge sacrifices to be heard, so why should we?

If there's a singer, there's a PA. Keep the set-up you like and use a mic instead. If it's a really loud environment (if it's not a jazz gig then aren't they all? 😉), get yourself some IEM (same price as a mouthpiece). Not only will it kill the volume, protecting your ears (I find much better than normal ear plugs), you get a perfect mix, too. The technology is 50 years old - even pub bands use them. There's no reason to struggle, no reason to compromise when there's a simple solution that will work in pretty much every situation you're ever likely to find yourself in.
Thanks for this, Dave. I've been watching the videos you've posted here (and have enjoyed them immensely) so you definitely have the experience to back up your words of advice.

Any advice/recommendations on IEMs?

Jim
 
While I can't disagree with any of the points above I've never found in-ear monitors comfortable to use. They always make me feel distanced from what's going on on stage- perfect sound but a vague feeling of detachment too....
 
While I can't disagree with any of the points above I've never found in-ear monitors comfortable to use. They always make me feel distanced from what's going on on stage- perfect sound but a vague feeling of detachment too....
Interesting.
As a boilermaker (welder), I spent most of my working life wearing ear plugs while working at oil refineries and coal-fired generating plants. Even as a musician (weekend warrior), I wore them but always felt, as you said, "distanced from what's going on". Twenty years ago, I bought a set of custom-moulded musician's earplugs with a 15 decibel baffle. While they're a step up from foam ear plugs, I still get that 'detached' feeling. I've never owned IEMs but have been looking at getting a pair.
 
Any advice/recommendations on IEMs?

Don't buy the cheapest you can find. If you get on with them (some people use just one ear bud so that they get the perfect mix in one ear and the ambient music in the other - musicians who grew up using wedges often seem to fall into this category), then you don't want to be replacing what is basically a brand new system with another brand new system three months later. Unless you are lucky enough to not be worried about cost then you don't need to buy an eye-wateringly expensive system, either.

You do want a system with more than one channel/frequency. Even if the band you're playing with at the moment don't use them, you may play in one that does in the not too distant future. And, if my experience is anything to go by, once one person in a band gets IEM, suddenly two people are using them. Then three, then four, then... 😉

The LD Systems MEI1000G2 is the one I've been using for a couple of years now. There are three people running them in the Spandau tribute, all with no real issues. The price seems to have jumped 20% over here in the UK over the last few months, though. It's not the best system money can buy, but it has (in my opinion) the best cost to performance ratio if you're not a professional touring musician.

The only issues I/we've had are the buds are worth replacing at some point. They're good enough to get the job done (I did loads of theatre gigs with them) but they're not as good as they could be. You may already have decent buds for your phone anyway, although they need to be wired. Wireless mics/sax mics that don't need a license can affect the signal. Make sure your sax mic receiver and your IEM receiver are more than 30cm apart and you'll be fine. Multiple IEM receivers next to each other cause no issues at all.

They can take a little getting used to, but then so does relying on wedges.
 
I like a big and full sound without amplification. A PA is just amplifying your tone. It doesn't matter how you sound, it make your tone louder. If we listen to all the guys that we think have a great big tone you will probably discover that they are playing with a full and big tone. A guy told that once opened up for King Curtis that it was the biggest and "loudest" tone he had ever heard. Red Prysock was also a guy with a full tone. And Clarence Clemons ...... . If I can, I play without amplification. To be loud with microphone and amplification is one thing. To be loud without amplification is another thing.
 
Don't buy the cheapest you can find. If you get on with them (some people use just one ear bud so that they get the perfect mix in one ear and the ambient music in the other - musicians who grew up using wedges often seem to fall into this category), then you don't want to be replacing what is basically a brand new system with another brand new system three months later. Unless you are lucky enough to not be worried about cost then you don't need to buy an eye-wateringly expensive system, either.

You do want a system with more than one channel/frequency. Even if the band you're playing with at the moment don't use them, you may play in one that does in the not too distant future. And, if my experience is anything to go by, once one person in a band gets IEM, suddenly two people are using them. Then three, then four, then... 😉

The LD Systems MEI1000G2 is the one I've been using for a couple of years now. There are three people running them in the Spandau tribute, all with no real issues. The price seems to have jumped 20% over here in the UK over the last few months, though. It's not the best system money can buy, but it has (in my opinion) the best cost to performance ratio if you're not a professional touring musician.

The only issues I/we've had are the buds are worth replacing at some point. They're good enough to get the job done (I did loads of theatre gigs with them) but they're not as good as they could be. You may already have decent buds for your phone anyway, although they need to be wired. Wireless mics/sax mics that don't need a license can affect the signal. Make sure your sax mic receiver and your IEM receiver are more than 30cm apart and you'll be fine. Multiple IEM receivers next to each other cause no issues at all.

They can take a little getting used to, but then so does relying on wedges.
Thanks, Dave. There's a lot of useful information in that reply and it's coming from someone with real-world first-hand experience.

And yes, prices are through the roof here as well. A USA-made Gibson J45 acoustic guitar went from $2400 CAD to $3500 CAD in less than a year. Canada and the USA have a 'free trade' agreement so there's no duty on USA-made goods.

Thanks again for the information.
Jim
 
so why do we tell each other to play louder, use louder, brighter mouthpieces? It makes no sense to play a mouthpiece you don't particularly like, that has a tone you don't want, at a volume you don't enjoy.
Rock & Roll saxophone and electric blues are loud genres. It's in the dna of the genre. With or without amp and microphone. I'm bright because I want to cut through. I often hear sax players that are not playing at the same range as the guitar player. To blend in with a Stratocastor a high baffled mouthpiece is fine. And if it's loud band, a wide tip opening and hard reed is also helping up. Most RockSax players comes from live scenes. To be heard they had to play loud and have a big tone. I love Rock & Roll Saxophones, my screaming Martin tenors, my .130" high baffled Rovner mouthpiece, a hard and stiff reed ...... Sometimes I have to push and blow a little bit harder to be heard. And I do lots of mistakes. I love it all.
 
I think you're missing the point a little. I'm not saying you shouldn't play big, raucous mouthpieces at high volume - I certainly have no plans of getting rid of my Jumbo Javas. I'm saying that I wish I'd known that I don't have to change what I play, how I play it and how I sound just because I find myself in a loud situation - there's technology, that's been around for decades, that doesn't (or didn't) cost more than a new mouthpiece, that allows me to play my set-up, the way I want to play it no matter what the situation.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom