Reeds The plastic reed debate.

Here is my testimonial:

I'll preface by stating that I'm about as ardent in my love for real cane reeds as one can get. They can be fussy to get into optimal playing order, and the lifespan isn't always what one wants, but the tone and response is incomparable.

However, I have not neglected the journey towards finding a suitable, if not ideal, synthetic reed over the years either. All of them have been either too buzzy, lackluster in tone, unresponsive in the lower register, unplayable at pianissimo level.......... well most are familiar with their general shortcomings.

That is, until I tried the new Fibracell Premiers. Without this sounding like a paid endorsement, I find these to be really impressive, and not just as synthetics go. I can get the same response, a full rich tone, reliable and familiar strength ratings, and all with less fuss and prep than cane reeds. They sound a wee bit brighter, but I generally play with a darker tone and setup. The slight, added brightness can often be a good balance. This also varies depending on what horn and setup I'm using.

I'm not giving up my cane reeds. But if nothing else, it is nice to have the Fibracells in my case ready to go. I have converted to these completely on baritone.

I'd have to rate the standard, clear BARI reeds as the overall worst synthetic reed for my taste and purposes. Unfortunately it plays about as sterile, unresponsive, and quacky as it looks like it would.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just bought my second three pack of Rico Royals with not one playable reed. Now playing my Legere Signature synthetic (tenor) and will not go back. Great dependable sound, and £20 (or a bit less at Reeds Direct) is well worth it when you consider how may cane reeds end up in the bin. Oddly I tried a Legere Studio alto reed and I didn't like it - can anyone recommend the best alto synthetic?
 
Very interesting stuff, and it just shows what a discerning bunch we are. I play my Jody jazz HR7 with a legere synthetic 3 or when i want a warmer sound with ( to my ears ) more depth i always go back to my vandoren's 3. The good thing about the legere is it gives my chops a good workout.
So difficult to recommend one or the other as we are all so different and in what sound we wish to achieve.
Phil
 
Forestone reeds

I did once try a synthetig Légère reed but after the short experimenting returned back to using proper cane reeds again. However, my curiosity has been raised after a long while in the (semi)synthetic alternatives as I was shopping for new cane reeds the other week and the seller there introduced some new semi-synthetic reeds that had just come in for sale. They're called Forestone and come from Japan. As they costed approx. 25 € per reed I decided not to buy them yet as I had no idea what strength would be equivalent to RJS #2M that I'm currently using. Instead I decided to have a go on the new Rico Reserves that I had heard good things about. Anyone tried the Forestone? If yes, what were your impressions about them? I'm not yet convinced that synthetic reeds would ever take the place of cane ones for me but this new kind of reed that's made of "a mixture of polypropylene resin and cellulose wood fibre" sure sounds interesting enough to try out sometime.

Have a look:
http://www.forestone-japan.com/current/eg/products.html

Ville
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I got my first synthetic reed a few days ago, a Fibracell for alto.
All the mucking about getting reeds into a comfortable condition only for them to go off shortly afterwards was really getting to me.

I was really pleasantly impressed by its readiness to speak, but slightly disappointed by it being a bit brighter than I wanted.
This perceived brightness now seems to have settled down, though I can't tell whether it is the reed or me that has changed.
Sustain also seemed to die at low volume/pressure but that appears to have resolved itself too.

The only question now is how long it maintains its performance, but for now I'm pretty pleased with it.
 
However, my curiosity has been raised after a long while in the (semi)synthetic alternatives as I was shopping for new cane reeds the other week and the seller there introduced some new semi-synthetic reeds that had just come in for sale. They're called Forestone and come from Japan.

Anyone tried the Forestone? If yes, what were your impressions about them?

Have a look:
http://www.forestone-japan.com/current/eg/products.html

Ville

I've had one a couple of days now, delivery was a week from order, not bad from Japan, I got a 2.5 and think it compares well to a Java 2.5 for strength. Very easy to play, doesn't "give your chops a workout" like the Legere, bright, I'm impressed so far and I would say nicer than the Fibracelle.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have, at one time or another tried just about every plastic reed there is for tenor, and have not found any I liked. I am just a newbie, though. I have only been playing professionally since 1963. For many years, I used one of PHil Rovener's soft plastic tenor reeds on bass clarinet, until one day, it made a sound like a duck and just died. As to finding only from three to six reeds in a box that are playable - I guess I am just not that discerning. I rarely find a reed in a box that I can't make work for me. But I play on very soft reeds, so maybe that is the difference. On tenor and bari, I am using LaVoz soft reeds, and rushing them down or sanding the back to make them a little softer. When I was playing for strip clubs, back in the late 1960's, I discovered the way to get a big sound and to blow all night without hurting myself was to use a really big mouthpiece, with a soft reed, and to roll my lower lip outward, like smoking a cigar. That way, I get a sound as big as your back yard, and don't hurt myself. Also, becasue I am not chewing them up, tenor and bari reeds generally last about two or three years for me. Often they get tossed out because I caught them on something; not becasue they wore out or died.

Just saw the post immediatly before mine and noted the strength - if I put a 2 or 21/2 ANYTHING on my horn, I my as well go out in my garage a pick up a 2x4 to use for a reed. LOL

(I do use 21/2 or3 Vandorens on clarinet, though. But that is an entirely different embouchure. It is much more vertical than sax. The reed is supported and damped by my lower teeth and merely cushioned by my lip.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fed up waiting for Legere Signature to be available on baritone and also disappointed by a long run of stuffy or short-lived cane reeds at £3 - £4 a shot, I ordered a Forestone 3 1/2 reed from Japan.

It arrived this morning, about one week after ordering, which seems reasonable to me. Imagine my disappointment when I unwrapped the parcel and found that the packaging said "Tenor Saxophone". But the packet looked as though I could open it without destroying it, so I went ahead. Just as well, as the reed inside is a baritone ! Either the tenor and baritone reeds share the same packaging, or someone in Japan made a mistake.

First impressions are very good - 3 1/2 is certainly the right strength for me and this one plays easily, without the reluctance to "speak" that I find on Legere standard reeds down the bottom end of the horn. The sound is quite bright, probably somewhere between Rico Royal and Plasticover, so that is fine for me on my darker sounding mouthpiece.

It will be interesting to see how long it lasts and whether I continue to like the sound.

Rhys

PS Having tried a lot of synthetic reeds, I prefer this Forestone reed to BARI, Hahn, Legere standard, Hartmann. Seems to be a little nicer than a good Fibracell too, but maybe not quite as good as Legere Signature.
 
Fed up waiting for Legere Signature to be available on baritone and also disappointed by a long run of stuffy or short-lived cane reeds at £3 - £4 a shot, I ordered a Forestone 3 1/2 reed from Japan.

It arrived this morning, about one week after ordering, which seems reasonable to me. Imagine my disappointment when I unwrapped the parcel and found that the packaging said "Tenor Saxophone". But the packet looked as though I could open it without destroying it, so I went ahead. Just as well, as the reed inside is a baritone ! Either the tenor and baritone reeds share the same packaging, or someone in Japan made a mistake.

First impressions are very good - 3 1/2 is certainly the right strength for me and this one plays easily, without the reluctance to "speak" that I find on Legere standard reeds down the bottom end of the horn. The sound is quite bright, probably somewhere between Rico Royal and Plasticover, so that is fine for me on my darker sounding mouthpiece.

It will be interesting to see how long it lasts and whether I continue to like the sound.

Rhys

PS Having tried a lot of synthetic reeds, I prefer this Forestone reed to BARI, Hahn, Legere standard, Hartmann. Seems to be a little nicer than a good Fibracell too, but maybe not quite as good as Legere Signature.

Hi Rhys

I have been thinking of trying one of these on alto but haven`t got round to it yet,also waiting for more reviews on them especially on how long they last etc,i am happy with using Fibracell premier but might give Forestone a try in the near future.

Brian
 
PS Having tried a lot of synthetic reeds, I prefer this Forestone reed to BARI, Hahn, Legere standard, Hartmann. Seems to be a little nicer than a good Fibracell too, but maybe not quite as good as Legere Signature.
I just discarded my first Forestone reed, after about a year of playing. I have four (had three) in my rotation, and one of them started to misbehave recently. I am very happy with the performance and durability of these reeds, and I highly prefer them over BARI and Fibracell reeds.
 
jthole - are you using forestone reeds on your alto as well? I have one of them, and it seems really hard, and seems to be only flexible at the very very tip of the reed, and it's near impossible to play with. Mine's a 2.5, iirc.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom