Tech/maintenance the physics of how saxes work

Thanks to Nick Wyver, kevgermany and others I've now got a lot of studying to do if I want to find out why C4 is hard to play softly, as per a question in another post. Thanks everyone. The link is great. What an interesting subject. Incidentally, some people said that leaks contribute to making this soft playing of C4 difficult and my tenor's lowest flap valves (I call them that through my ignorance of a better word), they leak a little. How can I fix them myself? Is there a simple way? The pads are not very worn, they just seem to come down "heel first" if you know what I mean.
 
In short, yes you can do it yourself, it requires a few tools and some patience, but it's do-able.

Pads should touch all the way around at the same time and seal with gentle finger pressure. You'll probably find that it's not only the lower pads that don't seal properly. If they touch heel first, either the pads are incorrectly seated, or they're too thick, or the keys are bent. Could also be a ding in the sax. The pads are held in with a heat sensitive glue (same as in glue guns), or shellac or sealing wax. All can be adjusted with a little heat from a spirit lamp. Make sure you keep the tone hole impression in the pads in complete alignment with the tone hole, otherwise you'll need to replce the pad, cos it won't seal otherwise.

Best starting point on sorting the pads out is to get a copy of Steven Howard's 'Haynes Saxophone Manual'. It's not expensive and will pay for itself very quickly.
 
Thanks to everyone who asnwered my question about the physics of how saxes work. My particular interest in this was dealt with in the reference to phys.unsw.edu.au/jw/saxacoustics.html. I can see now why even a small leak in the C3 pad makes it difficult to sound the note quietly.
 
Thank you Nick Wyver for the excellent lead to Joe Wolfe's UNSW article about the acoustics of tenor saxes. However, I still don't understand why a tenor cannot produce A flat 2 or B flat 2 as we transposers call it. The article says that there is a resonance there so why can't we play it? The length of a tenor is 1.48 metres and the speed of sound is 344 metres/sec so the first resonance occurs at 344/2x1.48 = 103.8 Hz which is A flat 2. I can see that the difference in acoustic impedance between A flat 2 and A flat 3 is 2x10 exp -7 (Pa per square metre), but is that sufficient for the lower note to refuse to sound if we blow hard enough?
 
The speed of sound is not a constant. In dry air at 20 °C (68 °F), the speed of sound is 343.2 metres per second whereas it travels about 4.3 times faster in water (1,484 m/s). At 35 °C the speed is 351.887 m/s, and that is not taking humidity into consideration. So depending of how moist and hot the 'climate' in your sax is, you probably never get to the Hz required for A2 flat. Honk as hard as you like 🙂
 
Thank you Nick Wyver for the excellent lead to Joe Wolfe's UNSW article about the acoustics of tenor saxes. However, I still don't understand why a tenor cannot produce A flat 2 or B flat 2 as we transposers call it. The article says that there is a resonance there so why can't we play it? The length of a tenor is 1.48 metres and the speed of sound is 344 metres/sec so the first resonance occurs at 344/2x1.48 = 103.8 Hz which is A flat 2. I can see that the difference in acoustic impedance between A flat 2 and A flat 3 is 2x10 exp -7 (Pa per square metre), but is that sufficient for the lower note to refuse to sound if we blow hard enough?

You might like to check the answers over at http://cafesaxophone.com/showthread.php?5869-lowest-playable-note-on-a-tenor.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom