Reeds Reed Strength and Dark or Bright Sound

A comfortable set up that lets you relax and play, allows you to focus on pitch and phrasing.
I'm not searching for comfort when I'm playing. The music I play is "loud", "sweaty", "shoulder to shoulder" and often out of tune. I don't tune my sax before I play on a jam. I just put the mouthpiece on the same mark on the cork as it was last time I played. How many are looking for the perfect pitch when you are playing on a jam? One evening a guy had a tuner on his guitar. He just played one song.
 
Im a bit peeved as i can only use legere or at a push plasticovers with the dynamics in the caravan..ive loads of cane reeds left over if anyone wants them..What i found was that taking a brand such as vandoren java red and green a red 2 was darker maybe the file difference? Though darker on a labayle jazz 7 high notes were harder to achieve..Going up a 3 red was to hard to play i got a buzzy sound the 3 green was nice low notes a bit harder to hit or tongue to be precise..just to throw it out there...i did find lig style rovner vs 2 screw metal table length on different pieces and lig position did make a difference on ease of blow..in the end a rigotti jazz 2.5 med was a good compromize..I think you have to find the compromize then put in the work to fill in whats missing..
 
I’ve never really noticed that but probably because I just play the strength that suits me. If I try a reed that happens to be too hard or soft I adjust embouchure accordingly so I suppose for me it’s impossible to say.
So you can play a reed that's far too hard and get the same sound as your normal reed, just by adjusting your embouchure? I wish I could do that. While I can make the wrong reed sound fine as far as the audience is concerned, I find reeds that are too hard very difficult to play, exhausting actually. But it is an instant way to darken my tone without any embouchure adjustments. That's not to say I do this on purpose. I'd much rather play what suits me. But if a reed dies on a gig, I may not have another suitable reed on hand and have to make do with what I've got. Yes, that's down to poor planning on my part, but it happens.
 
So you can play a reed that's far too hard and get the same sound as your normal reed
Well I did say "too hard" not "far too hard." Not the same thing IMO. There is a limit.

I used to play 4s, now I play 2 or 2.5. If I was to play a 4 now I would adjust my embouchure to what it was before I decided to go down to softer reeds. Not sure about 5s though.
 
Last edited:
We may be confusing loud with bright. A dark sound can still be very loud. To me bright just means more high frequency overtones in the sound, like cranking up the treble on your stereo. It’s physically impossible for really hards reeds to vibrate in that way, hence the lack of brightness compared to softer reeds. I can play extremely loud on hard reeds too. I just don’t get the full spectrum like on softer reeds. But there’s really no way to compete with amplified instruments with amplification yourself.
 
We may be confusing loud with bright.
Very easy to do, but we need to consider the use of the word loud.

It is nearly always used (subjectively) to describe the effect as opposed to the actual sound volume or sound (pressure) level measured in decibels.

As an example you can have two audio signals:

  1. One with a preponderance of high frequencies
  2. One with a preponderance of lower frequencies

They can both read the same level of decibels (SPL) but one can sound a lot louder than the other either by itself or else it might cut through in a specific mix.

Very often if a saxophone player uses a reed that adds high frequencies then it will both have a higher SPL and probably sound louder. But if the reed adds high frequencies and attenuates lower ones it may well have the same SPL but also sound louder.

However there is a double edged sword in playing brighter in order to be heard better in a mix. If the high frequencies you add (e.g. by a high baffle) are the same frequencies as other instruments then you may be lost in the mix, even though you may now have a higher SPL and a mouthpiece that sounds louder when you are playing by yourself or in a different line up.

Sometimes I have filtered out higher saxophone frequencies and found it easier to mix because it sits in an area of the frequency range where it is no longer competing.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,573
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom