Saxophone beginners Quality Sound - What Affects it the Most?

Some of it certainly is the player but especially when you compare yourself to some "other YouTubers" you can get frustrated very easily because they sound so great. But a major portion of that "pleasant" tone/sound is post-processing, electronic enhancement. Even a little bit of reverb can make all the difference.
So don't blame yourself when it really is the "digital enhancements" that make "them" sound so "great"

Some of them go completely overboard, like this young fella. He's got about 7 seconds of reverb and sustain added to his recording and be assured, the recording wasn't done on that wintery ruin, definitely not with the gloves he's wearing and if you look careful you can even see that he only holds his sax and doesn't move his fingers:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t3j9NgOAz98


Bottom line, don't try to look like him, don't try to sound like him, it won't happen :rolleyes::rolleyes::optimistic::optimistic:
No, I won't follow. Though to some of the ears this is pro, but I still think that it sounds muffling, which I don't want, rather, a tone that opens up, just like a blue sky, full of hope.
 
So you mean after my recordings I need to do something to the sound track to open up the sound?
I think that might depend on what you mean by open up the sound

The thread has now taken off into a different but related topic as it was originally about acoustic sound, we now have the added dimension of recorded sound and possibly a whole different topic that is no longer sound production, but post production of recorded sound.

which I don't want, rather, a tone that opens up, just like a blue sky, full of hope
So are you talking about achieving your sound yourself, or about using electronics to enhance it?
 
I think that might depend on what you mean by open up the sound

The thread has now taken off into a different but related topic as it was originally about acoustic sound, we now have the added dimension of recorded sound and possibly a whole different topic that is no longer sound production, but post production of recorded sound.


So are you talking about achieving your sound yourself, or about using electronics to enhance it?
About improving my playing techniques or instrument adjustments
 
Thanks Pete for allocating my thread to the right place, I think I need some advice on why the tone is somewhat muffling not good to the ears. I will take any suggestions for now.
 
Go see some live acoustic saxophone.
Comparing yourself to recordings is frustrating.
Self recording can be used as a tool to see how you're playing.
You cant expect a little furry mic poked into a phone to give you studio quality recordings.
It takes quite some time to get to grips with the saxophone.
There's lots to learn.
There are lots of informative threads on here and of course Taming the Saxophone.
The answer is never simple and will contain elements you've not even thought of.
4 hours a day practice for a decade is how to make a start. Then you can begin. 😉
 
Hi all,
After playing with my alto sax for 2 years with everyday practice, I have learned to play many play-along pop songs. Now I come to the point that I found the sound quality seems confined / restricted, not opened up compare to other Youtube performers online. It seems like the sound is coming from an enclosed box. Just wanna know what are the causes and suggestions to improve it. I have tried many different embouchure positions on the reed. Playing with loud voice and gentle sound; to no avail. It get even worse after the recording. Thanks.

I still remember a lot of helping hands here 2 years ago when I started playing.

YAS62
4C/5C
Légère 2.0/2.25
I can think of several obvious possibilities.

The first two are the most likely:
1. The most probably cause is the player - you. If you have only been playing for 2 years then it would be surprising if you sounded like a professional! You just need to keep practicing. But you may be biting or restricting the reed without realising it, so I would recommend some lessons, either online or in person so that a teacher can hear and see what you are doing.
2. I find that when I record myself I tend to play to the microphone and the result is rather restricted. You need to play past the microphone to a person at the bottom of the garden.

The next three may help, but a good recording system is not a substitute for good tone.
3. A poor sound recording system certainly won't help. There are threads here about home recording equipment.
4. Recording in an unsuitable location won't help either - a fairly dead room is best.
4. Adding some (tasteful) equalisation and reverberation will improve the recorded sound. This is easy to do if you are using a computer recording system such as GarageBand or Audacity.
 
Go see some live acoustic saxophone.
Comparing yourself to recordings is frustrating.
Self recording can be used as a tool to see how you're playing.
You cant expect a little furry mic poked into a phone to give you studio quality recordings.
It takes quite some time to get to grips with the saxophone.
There's lots to learn.
There are lots of informative threads on here and of course Taming the Saxophone.
The answer is never simple and will contain elements you've not even thought of.
4 hours a day practice for a decade is how to make a start. Then you can begin. 😉
So true
 
wow thanks for the immediate reply. You have given me hope fro my ability, So you mean after my recordings I need to do something to the sound track to open up the sound?
The thing is, no recording is equivalent to sitting right in front of a great player and hearing them in person.

So don't worry about how your recordings sound. Listen to a bunch of great players in person and try to emulate that.

I remember the first time I heard Larry Slezak warming up. His sound was so enormous; everything he did was larger than life. When he stepped out on stage and you were in the back row, he sounded energetic and dynamic. Right there six feet away, it was overpowering. (I don't mean just loud. When he played softly it was the same way.)

Recording wizardry cannot add sparkle and magic to a blah uncompelling sound.
 
Hi all,
After playing with my alto sax for 2 years with everyday practice, I have learned to play many play-along pop songs. Now I come to the point that I found the sound quality seems confined / restricted, not opened up compare to other Youtube performers online. It seems like the sound is coming from an enclosed box. Just wanna know what are the causes and suggestions to improve it. I have tried many different embouchure positions on the reed. Playing with loud voice and gentle sound; to no avail. It get even worse after the recording. Thanks.

I still remember a lot of helping hands here 2 years ago when I started playing.

YAS62
4C/5C
Légère 2.0/2.25
Tone building exercises.

I always recommend the same exercise: pppp to ffff back to pppp, over the full range of the horn. Allow the sound to break up at the dynamic extremes and learn how to rein it back in. You should do this every single time you get the horn out to practice. You should do this exercise outdoors, with no nearby reflective surfaces, as often as possible.
 
The thing is, no recording is equivalent to sitting right in front of a great player and hearing them in person.

So don't worry about how your recordings sound. Listen to a bunch of great players in person and try to emulate that.

I remember the first time I heard Larry Slezak warming up. His sound was so enormous; everything he did was larger than life. When he stepped out on stage and you were in the back row, he sounded energetic and dynamic. Right there six feet away, it was overpowering. (I don't mean just loud. When he played softly it was the same way.)

Recording wizardry cannot add sparkle and magic to a blah uncompelling sound.
You read my mind. That sound quality is what I after. I wanna play with a sound that I myself enjoy listening to repeatedly. I am running out of words to describe that sound quality, that has the gravity, intriguing, tenderly soft but at the same time firm and stable that you feel the propensity to lean on.
 
I can think of several obvious possibilities.

The first two are the most likely:
1. The most probably cause is the player - you. If you have only been playing for 2 years then it would be surprising if you sounded like a professional! You just need to keep practicing. But you may be biting or restricting the reed without realising it, so I would recommend some lessons, either online or in person so that a teacher can hear and see what you are doing.
2. I find that when I record myself I tend to play to the microphone and the result is rather restricted. You need to play past the microphone to a person at the bottom of the garden.

The next three may help, but a good recording system is not a substitute for good tone.
3. A poor sound recording system certainly won't help. There are threads here about home recording equipment.
4. Recording in an unsuitable location won't help either - a fairly dead room is best.
4. Adding some (tasteful) equalisation and reverberation will improve the recorded sound. This is easy to do if you are using a computer recording system such as GarageBand or Audacity.
Thanks, I know the way to go is make use of the those after recording effect to cover up my faults / dryness. I think your first point is useful. In playing quality sound one note at a time.
 
Tone building exercises.

I always recommend the same exercise: pppp to ffff back to pppp, over the full range of the horn. Allow the sound to break up at the dynamic extremes and learn how to rein it back in. You should do this every single time you get the horn out to practice. You should do this exercise outdoors, with no nearby reflective surfaces, as often as possible.
hmmm, bonne idée
 
The thing is, no recording is equivalent to sitting right in front of a great player and hearing them in person.

So don't worry about how your recordings sound. Listen to a bunch of great players in person and try to emulate that.

I remember the first time I heard Larry Slezak warming up. His sound was so enormous; everything he did was larger than life. When he stepped out on stage and you were in the back row, he sounded energetic and dynamic. Right there six feet away, it was overpowering. (I don't mean just loud. When he played softly it was the same way.)

Recording wizardry cannot add sparkle and magic to a blah uncompelling sound.
Even amateur theatres employ sound engineers and use expensive sound systems. It's all part of the illusion. 😉
 
Even amateur theatres employ sound engineers and use expensive sound systems. It's all part of the illusion. 😉
Go stand in front of Chris Potter when he's warming up in the green room, and tell me it's illusion. Nope, his great sound that comes out of the PA when he's on stage, starts with a great sound when he's at home practicing the C major scale.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,704
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom