Playing the saxophone Playing the Saxophone by Robert Buckland: A beginners viewpoint.

Rob Pealing

sax in a kayak (apprentice sax tamer)
Messages
1,053
Location
Greenfield, Nova Scotia, Canada
About six months ago @kevgermany suggested that I get this book, I looked it up, read the introduction to it on Robert Buckland’s web site and decided it was aimed at intermediate to advanced players and since I am neither did not pursue it any further. About three months ago in a different thread he made the suggestion again. This time I coughed up my $ and down loaded the PDF file and associated videos from Astute Music. I found it awkward to use on my laptop so it sat on the hard drive for a month or so till I took it to a UPS store and got it printed and bound. ( The copyright does allow you to print a copy for your own use)

I think the first thing to say is do not let the introduction on the web or in book put you off, there is a lot beginners can learn from this book.

The introduction and next three chapters introduce some concepts about how to to learn to develop your skills, I skimmed these and when I got on a bit further realised I would have to go back and read it again, because it is the foundation of your playing, learning and the book.

Subsequent chapters start with the very first steps: posture, saxophone position etc. and move through finger position and movement, breathing, starting and stopping a note, focusing the air, gradually introducing new topics and ideas, giving practice exercises.

The book then works its way through to advanced techniques eg microtonal fingering adjustments, extended techniques ( mutiphonics, bisgbigliando, mouth ram, etc)

The chapter on scales is one chapter I paid special attention to, he is very keen that students play scales, however he is also keen that they are played correctly right from the start, he says “play the scale SO slowly that you only move to the next note when you KNOW that it is the right note” He explains why this is important and later he explains why scales are important and gives ideas to make practising them less onerous.

One of the recurring ideas in the book is

“STOP
THINK
PLAY. (Keep going – do not allow yourself to stop)”


As opposed to

“PLAY
STOP - at the first mistake
THINK - but this is too late, and you are thinking of the mistake, Very demoralising.”


There is something for all players in this book and especially if like me you learn by understanding what you are trying to achieve and how the equipment you are using works.
 
I've had this book for a few years. After skim-reading through it, like Rob, I concluded it was too advanced for me. Now I refer to it from time to time when I need it. Gradually, as I improve, more of it is making sense to me and helping me to progress.
 
This book is excellent. But it can be a little ott when you first start. As an introductory book, Larry Teal's The Art of Saxophone Playing is easier. But when you're having problems, especially when there's no tutor around, Buckland helps a lot.
 
Thanks for the heads up Rob

I have been using the (recommended by lots of members) Smart Music Program for the past 2-3 weeks. I have found this very good as it records me playing the wrong notes.

I am finding myself for the first time starting to 'read' the music and think that this will really help my progress. There is a lot on there for beginners, but most importantly, It is more fun and interactive than a book. When I look at the dots, I have trouble thinking what it should sound like, but with the interactive solution I can look at it..think what it should sound like...then play it and see how wrong I was. I find books harder in this respect, although a lot of books do have links to MP3 files, or include CD.

My first month is almost up, and I am very happy with my progress so far and have a lot of things to practice daily. Thinks are definitely getting a little easier, but it is very frustrating when I get a day I can't practice on the sax and have to revert to theory instead.

I will have a look at the site you recommend 🙂
 
Thanks for the heads up Rob

I have been using the (recommended by lots of members) Smart Music Program for the past 2-3 weeks. I have found this very good as it records me playing the wrong notes.

I am finding myself for the first time starting to 'read' the music and think that this will really help my progress. There is a lot on there for beginners, but most importantly, It is more fun and interactive than a book. When I look at the dots, I have trouble thinking what it should sound like, but with the interactive solution I can look at it..think what it should sound like...then play it and see how wrong I was. I find books harder in this respect, although a lot of books do have links to MP3 files, or include CD.

My first month is almost up, and I am very happy with my progress so far and have a lot of things to practice daily. Thinks are definitely getting a little easier, but it is very frustrating when I get a day I can't practice on the sax and have to revert to theory instead.

I will have a look at the site you recommend 🙂

Eugene Rousseau's book Practical Hints on Playing the Alto Saxophone, is also useful and is aimed at the complete beginner , but at the end of a year will be of little value to you, see if you can borrow it. Rob Buckland's book will keep you going for several years, I do not have a copy of the one that Kevin mentioned above so cannot comment on it.

 
No doubt Rob Buckland has authored an excellent method book for those starting to play the saxophone. I have not yet had to opportunity to study his book in detail, however there are a few observations that I wish to make with regard to his set of videos to accompany the method online.

Many of his concepts and ideas are in line with what is mainstream saxophone pedagogy, but a few of them are in fact quite different.
  1. A diminuendo from mf to pp on a long tone is done "entirely muscularly" using just the embouchure. Typically dynamics are controlled primarily by the amount of air though less reed is taken in when playing to the end of a diminuendo.
  2. Vibrato can be done with a "sawtooth wave" either going down fast, up slow or the reverse. Traditional vibrato is taught as a smooth rolling (sine) wave regardless of the speed or style of the music.
  3. When playing jazz articulations, the jaw moves up and down. Traditional articulation is done with no jaw movement whether it is jazz or classical styling. Effects such as scoops, drops, etc. are the exception.
Obviously Rob Buckland is a very fine player and these ideas and concepts work for him. I feel it is important to note that there are other very fine players who get excellent results teaching concepts and methods that are are different from those listed above.
 
No doubt Rob Buckland has authored an excellent method book for those starting to play the saxophone.
The first sentence of the Introduction to Rob Burckland.s book "Playing the Saxophone" is:
"This book is written for students of the saxophone who have reached a point where they want to start taking their playing to the next level."
The book is also described as "a multi-dimensional approach using technical understanding to enable creative and artistic freedom".
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,701
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom