Theory & Impro Playing the head first? Then improvising? Doing both in the same chorus? Sax vlog

Messages
514
Location
rome
Playing the melody first and then improvising is like having two different roles. But, what happens if we do both in the same chorus? I'm not talking about alternating 2, 4 or 8 bars each, but playing and improvising in a more unusual and creative way. This is extermely useful to improve both the song form and the melody of a tune.
Leave a comment to let me know your impression.
Have a good week-end!

P.S. Turn on English subtitles in the menu

View: https://youtu.be/4L33XLHpGHA
 
Yes @Colin the Bear , I agree.
@Karolis I agree woth Colin, this is more playing the melody and filling. This Hawkins' 1939 version is one of the most beautiful ones ever. I remember that almost twenty years ago I used to study improvisation with a very good teacher at home that asked me if I knew this song. I told him that I didn't know thus versions, but I knew body and soul. He told me "if you want to study with me pull edevry note by hear from Hawkins. Don't came here for a lesson if you don't want to do it." And I came back with the song after two weeks of super intense study...
 
Borrowing themes and melodies from other songs, by different composers to the one you're playing, can be interesting.

The way different composers negotiate a melody through the same chord sequence can be as informative and useful as listening to improvisations.

If I could play like Hawkins...well...who knows.

I've heard it said that referencing the melody in an improvisation helps the listener. You pick up any one who's lost and let those who aren't have a breather before we all press on together.
 
Hawkins's version of "Body and soul" is far from just referencing and filling. You should study it more thoroughly.
I know Karolis, and I consider it a masterpiece. But in the video I talked about a different thing. Alternating the head and improvisation in a more unusual way. This was intended to be an exercise to help us both on song form and also to be able to pick the melody in a more unusual points. The Hawkins playing is of course much more artistic than that, and his level of playing and improvising us stellar and unquestionable, of course. Everybody needs to study Hawkins, and certainly I am no exception. I also remember an another great version by Hawkins and Benny Carter on VHS, which I used to practice on, but I need to find the tape...
 
Most of the pre bebop era solos were based on the melody. Hence the "melodic" approach to improvisation. Then Charlie Parker ( and I'm sure some others) discovered that they can base their solos more on the harmony, not the melody the music changed forever. Filling in between the melody is also a wonderful way of soloing. I always loved the way Coltrane compliments Johnny Hartman with his subtle soloing in between the melody of the vocalist, not intruding, but enriching.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom