Playing the saxophone Piano man

eb424

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,216
Location
london
Hi

I am having a bit of an existensial crisis...I am not sure if piano man sounds right for the tenor sax. I really want it to but am not sure..Does anyone want to or can anyone try my version and give me feed back..It should hopefully play to the original but its not a score and shouldn't breach copy right...Thanks
 
I have my notes i just play along to you tube. Thanks for replying tho..sounds like your honking again.. 🙂
Yes, been playing for some weeks.

When I write "I can't", it means, I don't want because the song doesn't encourages me to play. Not a song that I can/want to voice on the sax.

Are playing all the letters you write above you words? If you tongued all notes is very staccato? Joel is telling a story.

When I'm playing melodies and songs with lyrics I try to listen to other sax players. It's nothing wrong to borrow from other players. Most sax players are "stealers".😉 Try to play it your way. Play your good stuff. Stay out of what you are not playing so well. "Piano man" alto or tenor song? What's is best for you. You are playing alto as well?

View: https://youtu.be/cgnfKKBaCZk

View: https://youtu.be/eOkJxV62_Vg

View: https://youtu.be/NGLerhBUhT8

View: https://youtu.be/EvrD8Bs1_08

View: https://youtu.be/wvurnfL777w

Piano Man - Billy Joel [ SAXOPHONE COVER ]
Piano Man- PIANO/SAX COVER by Mr. Selfridge & John Grecia
 
Piano Man is a song that really needs the lyrics to be interesting. The melody by itself is just a big ball of nothing. There are tunes like that.

Then there are tunes where the lyrics add almost too much - think of Misty. Easy to get a lot of juice out of it as an instrumental, with all the different chords and intervals, but not that easy to sing and some of the lyrics are a bit tortured to fit the melody.
 
Piano Man is a song that really needs the lyrics to be interesting. The melody by itself is just a big ball of nothing. There are tunes like that.

Then there are tunes where the lyrics add almost too much - think of Misty. Easy to get a lot of juice out of it as an instrumental, with all the different chords and intervals, but not that easy to sing and some of the lyrics are a bit tortured to fit the melody.
I couldn't agree more. When I think of some great ballads like Misty, Sophisticated Lady. So I imagine that these were written originally as tunes and then words were added afterwards. I might be wrong but some songs do sound like words were crowbarred into the melody as it were.

I am in danger of getting into trouble now if I seem to be disparaging those lyricists, but I can just imagine Johnny Mercer scratching his head over the line to follow waiting round the bend. I mean what on earth is a huckleberry friend? (Rhetorical question BTW)

Back on topic:

I agree about Piano Man, probably one of the last songs I would choose to do as an instrumental. Maybe second to last.
 
Last edited:
TBF i was having doubts hence the thread..but in my defence I dont think any of the 20 songs are classic sax..Just for a sing-a-long-a-sax in the care home..ok dream a little dream and i cant stop loving you aside..hmm and stranger on the shore maybe difficult to sing a long to..lol
 
TBF i was having doubts hence the thread..but in my defence I dont think any of the 20 songs are classic sax..Just for a sing-a-long-a-sax in the care home..ok dream a little dream and i cant stop loving you aside..hmm and stranger on the shore maybe difficult to sing a long to..lol
If you want ideas I have many, but maybe start a new thread specifically for Care Home repertoire
 
Yes, been playing for some weeks.

When I write "I can't", it means, I don't want because the song doesn't encourages me to play. Not a song that I can/want to voice on the sax.

Are playing all the letters you write above you words? If you tongued all notes is very staccato? Joel is telling a story.

When I'm playing melodies and songs with lyrics I try to listen to other sax players. It's nothing wrong to borrow from other players. Most sax players are "stealers".😉 Try to play it your way. Play your good stuff. Stay out of what you are not playing so well. "Piano man" alto or tenor song? What's is best for you. You are playing alto as well?

View: https://youtu.be/cgnfKKBaCZk

View: https://youtu.be/eOkJxV62_Vg

View: https://youtu.be/NGLerhBUhT8

View: https://youtu.be/EvrD8Bs1_08

View: https://youtu.be/wvurnfL777w

Piano Man - Billy Joel [ SAXOPHONE COVER ]
Piano Man- PIANO/SAX COVER by Mr. Selfridge & John Grecia
Thanks @thomsax answered my question..deep followed by high or all high..I prefered deep to hihh but am no wondering alto or tenor..lol
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom