Mouthpieces Old SML mouthpiece; leave as is, or having it opened up?

jthole

Member
Messages
337
Many years ago, I got an old SML baritone mouthpiece for free. It landed in a cupboard because it was way too closed for bigband playing. But last week I tried it again on a loaner baritone (a Keilwerth made Schenkelaars, different story). It turns out the SML (thick and round hard rubber mouthpiece, virtually no baffle) actually plays very nice on that sax, with an "old jazz" sound. But it's still way more closed than I am used to, so it lacks the volume I want.

Of course I could send it to a specialist to get it refaced and opened to e.g. an OL #7 size. But would it keep the same characteristics (tone, tuning) or will I end up with a completely different piece? Or should I accept it for what it is, play it with hard(er) reeds, and keep it original? I don't think it's very valuable, by the way; my guess is SML just used something like a Riffault blank and put their name on it.

Thanks!
 
Its not that valuable but as you want to maintain its character Id suggest opening only modestly.

Well, since you are the specialist I had in mind to contact, maybe I should send you some more details (maybe not interesting for everyone) in a PM.

What I like is the roundness, and how well it seems to tune with the Keilwerth/Schenkelaars (New King?). It's more mellow than my Meyer, and certainly way more than my Metalite ;-) But I am not sure if it's worth having it opened up, of if I'd better save up for a modern large chamber lowish baffle piece.

Would OL #6'ish in dimensions be beyond "modestly opened up"?

Thanks!
 
How much it will change depends on iys current tip size if you can measure or guess it. As it opens it will need a little extra baffle to compensate. As far as it being worth doing. A reface is about 145 euro. A new and well made mouthpiece is considerably more.
Market wise its not worth it since you wont get a lot out of the piece if you sell it. However if its worth it to you to play then it’s worth it.
How much you can open it also depends on if there is material in the tip to cut into. If the beak is sharp it limits how far you can take it.
 
As you say it's very likely to have been made by Riffault which should mean it's a great design and excellent hard rubber. I have Riffault mouthpieces for baritone with various badges on them (including SML) and they are great.

Does it have a facing mark on it like R4 or something and does it also say Made in France and Steelite Ebonite ?

My advice would be to play it with stronger reeds than you are used to and see whether that gives more volume and still a good sound. Unless you want lots of edge it should be a very good piece and you can get a bit of brightness by using different reeds such as Vandoren Java or Plasticovers.

Some more information about Riffault mouthpieces here, including a picture from their catalogue which gives tip openings.

If you do have it opened then I wouldn't go larger than a Link 6* and make sure you use a refacer who knows baritone pieces and facings.

Rhys
 
I had an original SML very closed tip alto mouthpiece. I had it opened then regretted it because it was still "vintage stuffy" That is rude shorthand for "classical".

So IMO you'd be better off keeping it as an original bit of case candy and getting a really good mouthpiece elsewhere (No hard sell gratuitous marketing here but...)
 
Fleshing out what others have said, in the details:

- probably, based on Pete's reply, you can open the facing without "A" shaped walls causing a disaster. That's nice.

- when you (meaning whoever does the refacing) opens the tip, that will bring the floor of the baffle up, in effect, unless they do it by changing the table instead of the facing, i.e. unless they file from the heel of the table, first, until it evens up and creates a larger tip opening (vs the flat of the table) without changing the tip area at all. But that's not how most refacers will do it unless you ask for it, and even then...I dunno. But taking the facing down at the tip to open up the opening will bring the baffle closer to the reed, in effect, changing how the scale balances, how notes articulate, etc., so that afterward, if you are trying to preserve those things, the baffle has to be reworked.

The bottom line is that you're not likely to get the same piece back that you sent. That can be good or bad, depending on what the refacer likes vs what you like, and if the refacer even cares to match your wants. Some do, some don't. Some relate well to others, some don't.

It doesn't sound like you're really that in love with the SML piece. In your shoes, if I was curious about a refacer, that would be an opportunity to see whether that person and I jibe, if what they do matches what I would like to have/get.

There are great refacers whose pieces you will not like, and some unknown unvaunted ones whose pieces you will. I think John Thomas (used to be in Gainesville, FL, not sure if he is still there now) is getting some renown now. I had a Resochamber Link for tenor he refaced for me years and years ago that I wish I could un-re-sell, and have back (but not for the $1200 it would probably cost, today). At that time (I don't know about now), there was nothing that fancy (no hairline rails, no finish-fetish finish) about his refacing by today's visual-candy standards, but even as someone quietly in the game for 20+ years, he has a lot less renown than some hot-stuff figures whose work is outstanding -- objectively, outstanding -- but just not personally for me, but that is the one piece I ever sold that I really, really want back. Maybe I would like a rubber Berg refaced to .130 by Theo 20 years ago, just to be able to measure and look at it and see what he was doing with them, back then.
 
Stick a hard reed on it. I use a Vandoren blue 4 on an S80 C*. Royal 5 is about the same strength.
Check the length of the vamp. I find Vandoren blue have the longest.
Some baritone reeds have a shorter vamp than the window on the S80.
Once refaced it's not original.
It may play better and keep its characteristics with a light dressing to level tip, rails and table.
 
I didn't have any harder reeds than Vandoren Traditional 2.5 (placed upwards as much as possible), but for a quick test I put a tenor sax reed on it. I like the timbre, and (with the Vandoren baritone reed) the tuning is remarkable.

I'm already convinced to take the harder reed route first. I'll order some Vandorens in different cuts and strengths.

(Maybe I’ll just get the table and rails flattened)
 
Last edited:
When I was looking for Schenkelaars info I also found some sales info about SML mouthpieces. Just alto and tenor. No bari mpc. From 78/79.
smlmun.JPG
 
@Richard@D'Addario is on here and may have a suggestion for their reeds too.
Maybe PM him, link to this thread, and ask him to suggest what reed/s may help?
He was helpful with tenor reeds for me, and his suggestion worked.

In the meantime I found that Rico Jazz Select 3H reeds are a very good match. I also found that this mouthpiece is not great for soloing in our small combo; it has a very warm sound, but doesn't stand out enough otherwise. It would be very nice for a sax quartet, but for the combo I'll stick to my Meyer.

(I might still consider the refacing route, if that also makes it slightly less dark; say between an OL Tone Edge and how it is now)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom