Tech/maintenance Octave mechanism issue on old alto

saxmad

Member
Messages
110
Location
North Norfolk
For some unknown reason I couldn't upload a video so stills are attached instead.

Without me pressing the octave key in the lower register when I move from G (1st photo) to A (2nd) the octave key pin moves, thus wanting to open the crook pad! but I want to remain in the lower register - any ideas??

The 3rd is a better view of the mechanism.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3883.webp
    IMG_3883.webp
    25.7 KB · : 214
  • IMG_3895.webp
    IMG_3895.webp
    24.6 KB · : 198
  • IMG_3900.webp
    IMG_3900.webp
    33.4 KB · : 206
It is difficult to see in the photos provided, but somewhere on the thumb key there should be a part or extension that holds the neck octave lever down until the thumb key is pressed. If you can find that, check to see if a piece of cork has come off.
 
Those old mechs can be really nasty to set up.
It's what I call an 'active' mech - which means that there's more than one spring powering the mech, which also means that those springs have to be perfectly balanced against each other. Then chuck in the fact that all the separate parts have to be perfectly regulated to each other and you're looking at a lot of headache.

It's really hard to see exactly what's going on without the horn on the bench, but the basic overview is that those two levers (extending to the right) off the thumb key disable the mech until the thumb key is pressed. This is to prevent the mech from functioning when playing in the lower octave.
So the source of your problems is likely to be that key...though that doesn't mean the mech doesn't have other issues.

But I'll tell you what strikes me...and that's that I can't see a spring on the thumb key. Might just be a bad angle on the shot, but it doesn't look like anything's sitting in the spring cradle. Can't be that simple, can it?

Fixing it over the internet ain't gonna be fun, and your best bet would be to try wrapping masking tape around each of those rightward arms in turn until something happens! Ultimately, though, you might be dealing with a bent (very) vintage mech - which is something that often causes even an experienced tech to puzzle over for a while.
 
Put the neck on and try again.

Press the thumb octave key. The neck key should open 3mm or more.

While still holding the thumb octave key
Press the G key. The mechanism should retract the neck lever(3-4mm) clearing the halo and allow the body PIP key to open.

I am highly suspicious your issue is dirt. It doesn’t take much for this area to become sticky and fail. Making spring adjustments is just compensating for dirty
parts.
 
Those old mechs can be really nasty to set up.
It's what I call an 'active' mech - which means that there's more than one spring powering the mech, which also means that those springs have to be perfectly balanced against each other. Then chuck in the fact that all the separate parts have to be perfectly regulated to each other and you're looking at a lot of headache.

But I'll tell you what strikes me...and that's that I can't see a spring on the thumb key. Might just be a bad angle on the shot, but it doesn't look like anything's sitting in the spring cradle. Can't be that simple, can it?

Fixing it over the internet ain't gonna be fun, and your best bet would be to try wrapping masking tape around each of those rightward arms in turn until something happens! Ultimately, though, you might be dealing with a bent (very) vintage mech - which is something that often causes even an experienced tech to puzzle over for a while.
I’ve done quite a few of these old ones. None are ever the same. One bit a little bent can ruin your day. The spring tension needs to be spot on in relationship to each other. Including the neck key arm Spring.

I see exactly what you’re talking about with the missing spring. That’s a big issue if it’s missing. The wire will need to be matched.
E07A3DE3-9FA0-4C55-A4C4-AFF0050F4DCD.webp

Just hold your sax out the kitchen window so I can see itπŸ˜‰
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom