Tech/maintenance Noisy octave mechanism

My guess is actually just below the lowest circled area above where the thumb key lever touches the see-saw lever. That one can get a little clanky. Annoying when silently pressing keys, but inaudible when actually playing. My horn makes lots of little clanks that I just live with.

As a previous bassoon player, I learned to put up with a LOT of clanks. If you listen to bassoon recordings, the lil’ clanks and rattles are inherent to the instrument. The sax is very forgiving with regard to its signal to noise ratio.
 
Get a tie clip type tiny mic and wave it around the relevant areas. It might be possible to work out the location of the noise.
Much what I did. The bit of kit I used was an Enhanced Audio Receiver. Highly recommended. You get a kit of two, highly sensitive receivers and a processing unit to achieve localisation using Local ISometry TElemaNtary intonING©.
 
Last edited:
Much what I did. The bit of kit I used was an Enhanced Audio Receiver. Highly recommended. You get a kit of two, highly sensitive receivers and a processing unit to achieve localisation using Local ISometry TElemaNtary ©.

You have the right tools. 😉

If you take the neck off the body, can you still detect the same clanks by cycling the parts separately?
 
:doh: I would’ve thought this was done before ever making the first post.
Aye, to folks like you and I it's obvious - but over the years I've found that you just can't rely on "the bleedin' obvious" when it comes to the general public. I'm seldom surprised these days, but often amused...which is no bad thing.
 
@greenstripe check tolerances here ?
View attachment 23639

So there was a bit of play - the ends of the se-saw bar (for want of a better word have a slot in so they can be made larger or smaller I have adjusted slightly and tried packing with silicone grease as a test. - no difference really.

Try oiling the mechanism?
Yes it's oiled and moves very freely, hence trying the silicone grease over the Ultimax high viscosity that I normally use.

The other thing I can think of is reducing the spring pressure on the G key so it springs open with a bit less force - if I'm correct this is the source of the energy.

I'm thinking I should learn to live with it until it goes in for the next service.
 
There's something odd about the clicking noise. To me it sounds more like something hitting the body tube rather than two keys clanking together.
There's also a slight noise when the top stack keys are released.
So try this: Press the octave key down and finger a G. Now, press the body octave key down with your finger or a pokey stick (as though the G key was pressing down on it). See if the noise is still present. If it is then it's definitely the octave mech at fault. If it's not then it points to a problem with the top stack.
 
There's something odd about the clicking noise. To me it sounds more like something hitting the body tube rather than two keys clanking together.
There's also a slight noise when the top stack keys are released.
So try this: Press the octave key down and finger a G. Now, press the body octave key down with your finger or a pokey stick (as though the G key was pressing down on it). See if the noise is still present. If it is then it's definitely the octave mech at fault. If it's not then it points to a problem with the top stack.
That’s why I originally thought the crook key was hitting on tube. Sounds like body contact not mechanism clank.
 
That’s why I originally thought the crook key was hitting on tube. Sounds like body contact not mechanism clank.
It does, doesn't it? Key on key noise is generally much more 'tinny', This sounds like something clanking against the body tube. Hard to tell from a video, of course.
 
Ah, I never listened to the recording before now. Sounds like the neck octave lever is hitting the neck tube. Either bend it a little or glue some felt under the arms near the pivot on the neck. You can probably reproduce by lifting the end of the lever at the neck pip quickly and completely. You'll see where it hits then.
 
Ah, I never listened to the recording before now. Sounds like the neck octave lever is hitting the neck tube. Either bend it a little or glue some felt under the arms near the pivot on the neck. You can probably reproduce by lifting the end of the lever at the neck pip quickly and completely. You'll see where it hits then.
It sounds like that to me, but the OP says it isn't happening.
 
Clink-Clunk-Clink-Clunk-Clink-Clunk-
I listened again. The actions making two different sounds. One on opening and one on closing the G.
Replace the black pin covering. It may have gone hard.
1692305984046.webp

Or buy a C melody. Well known for being quiet.
 
I fixed it!

Thanks everyone that suggested solutions.

I took a slow motion video and couldn't really see the octave pin touching the body:

View: https://youtu.be/Y3cxvll-8dU


But when I placed a pad dryer under the cork it stopped it making the noise - so handy these things and not just for drying the pads after playing!

BG pad dryer.webp



So I replaced the cork on the back of this part of the mech.

Before:


IMG_20230819_144249.webp



After - It's overhanging a little - will neaten and clean it it up a little after a day or so once the contact adhesive has cured.

IMG_20230819_155859.webp


Then I found I had to rebalance the spring tensions on the crook key and G keys

View: https://youtube.com/shorts/bu1owBVHv7k?feature=share
 
That shouldn't, technically, have stopped the noise because the sound came when that key (the pin or lifter key) was on its way up...at least according to the video. However, the sound does rather tie in with something hitting the body...so maybe there was a synch problem.
I think what the problem may have been is excess play in the swivel mech - and a thicker piece of cork under the pin key imparts some extra strain to the mech which in turn takes up a bit of the wear.

But anyway, fixed for now!
 
I'm wondering if the
That shouldn't, technically, have stopped the noise because the sound came when that key (the pin or lifter key) was on its way up...at least according to the video. However, the sound does rather tie in with something hitting the body...so maybe there was a synch problem.
I think what the problem may have been is excess play in the swivel mech - and a thicker piece of cork under the pin key imparts some extra strain to the mech which in turn takes up a bit of the wear.

But anyway, fixed for now!
I don't think the video was particularly out of sync. The mechanism was clearly bouncing - so the pin would hit the ring of the crook key twice - whether it was rebounding back off the body, I thought unlikely but couldn't tell for sure - at least at rest with no keys pressed no parts of the mech touched the body other than the cork.

It could well be wear or some other poor adjustment/fitting. I do find the degree of finishing on some of the parts a little rough and ready on the bits you can't normally see once you start taking this saxophone to bits. On my SR tenor the ends of the swivel sit in little Teflon cups. But my Teacher's alto which is a Signature Custom Raw seems to be an almost identical deign to mine.

Anyway, fixed for now ...and hopefully a bit longer
 
I’m convinced your cork simply limited the travel so the neck lever stopped hitting the neck. The metal is too thick at the tenon to make the sound I heard in your recording. In any case, glad you got it sorted
 
Well we never really had a picture from this angle showing the cork.
B86268DF-2D30-497D-AA7A-6EB5F424A316.webp

The mechanism shouldn’t actually stop on the black pin but that’s all I could see. I agree with the above comments. The additional cork may be putting some pre-load on the assembly. This is not allowing it to completely relax to the point where it’s loose. Glad you got it sorted and thanks for posting the results.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,569
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom