Beginner Saxes New saxophone for a Beginning saxophone player in the Netherlands.

Hello, I’m exploring the world of tenor saxophones. I live in the Netherlands. I would like Some help in making a choice between te next saxophones.
Travor James Classic ii
c.g. Conn ts 650
Jupiter jts500
Buffet 100 series
This are al new saxophone within my budget.
Please help me on information because of some saxophones there’s very little to find on the internet, especialy the Conn ts 650.
Excuse me for my englisch typing, it’s not the best.
I believe the Trevor James is a Chinese brand with some history behind it. In common with most of the Chinese el cheapos, it could come from People's Saxophone-Shaped Product Factory No.17 this month and from People's Musical Instrument Factory No. 32 next month.

The "Conn" has absolutely NOTHING to do with the classic Conn saxophones made from the early 1900s through the early 70s. It's a Chinese that MIGHT in theory have some QC imposed by the Selmer-Conn company that contracts with the Chinese factory to make it.

The Jupiter is a Taiwanese, actually made in its own (KHS) factory. These are starting to have a pretty decent reputation.

The "Buffet" has nothing to do with the classic Buffet saxophones made in France from the early 1900s through about the 1980s or later. I don't know whether it's a Chinese or a Taiwanese, it MIGHT in theory have some QC imposed by the Buffet/Keilwerth (?) company that contracts with the overseas factory to make it.

Frankly I think a used Yamaha or Jupiter at E1000 would be a far better deal than any of these.
 
And then there's Thomann.
I have the alto and it is excellent.
 
@Targa I’ve played the tenor sax for 2 years. I stopped because I started a study for work . Then I had a stroke. I sold my previous sax because I thought I would not plat again. Now two years later I’m feeling great and want to pick up the sax again.
Some one is offering me an Amati ats 62 tha’s been overhauled. I’m thinking of bying the sax because of the retailers good reputation and the things I read on the internet. What do you folks think?
 
It's important to keep in mind that with these Chinese made horns, the name printed on them doesn't say anything about the factory it came out of or how it was designed. Any company that's willing to order a sufficient quantity can get anything engraved on them they want.

As far as I know the "Conn" "Trevor James" and "Buffet" all fall into this category, although there are indications that all three are paying the "oh, you want us to build these with all the parts on and tighten the screws" premium. So they're probably serviceable but nothing special.

Jupiter is its own company (brand name of KHS) and Jupiter saxophones, as far as I know, are built in the KHS factory in Taiwan.

If those were the only choices I'd go Jupiter.

If you can open your mind to something else I'd go for a Yamaha, any model, that fits your budget and is in good condition. Buy from a shop with repair facilities and make sure they've gone through it first.
 
Some one is offering me an Amati ats 62 tha’s been overhauled.
the 62's were the top of the Amati line from the 90's, (they copied the Yamaha numbering system) - never tried one but try it out that's the way to go.
I had horns from that part of the world in the 80's and 90's. They were all good solid horns.
AFAIK They're modelled after the JK horns so should be solid build.
Go try it out, if you played for a couple of years you should know your way around the horn.

Hope you've not suffered damage from the stroke. I had a couple of strokes three years ago that among other things screwed up my embouchure, but I've gradually learned to deal with it. In fact I'm living proof that sax playing is excellent stroke therapy. I wish you well.
 
I'd keep an eye out for a used Yamaha YTS-23. They're made in Japan and are a discontinued model. Some, if not all of newer beginner and intermediate models are made in China.
Student Yamaha saxes are not made in China, they're made in Indonesia. I have played several, and their quality is on the same level as the Japanese made ones.
 
I believe the Trevor James is a Chinese brand with some history behind it. In common with most of the Chinese el cheapos, it could come from People's Saxophone-Shaped Product Factory No.17 this month and from People's Musical Instrument Factory No. 32 next month.

The "Conn" has absolutely NOTHING to do with the classic Conn saxophones made from the early 1900s through the early 70s. It's a Chinese that MIGHT in theory have some QC imposed by the Selmer-Conn company that contracts with the Chinese factory to make it.

The Jupiter is a Taiwanese, actually made in its own (KHS) factory. These are starting to have a pretty decent reputation.

The "Buffet" has nothing to do with the classic Buffet saxophones made in France from the early 1900s through about the 1980s or later. I don't know whether it's a Chinese or a Taiwanese, it MIGHT in theory have some QC imposed by the Buffet/Keilwerth (?) company that contracts with the overseas factory to make it.

Frankly I think a used Yamaha or Jupiter at E1000 would be a far better deal than any of these.
Agree with most of this, other than that Trevor James sources its cheaper saxes from Taiwan (its expensive ones are assembled in the UK from bits made in Taiwan) and the Buffet definitely are made in China.
 
Do you have any first hand experience with the Buffet? I used to have one and found the build quality far better than any student Yamaha. Tone was too dark for my taste, but it was a fine horn. And since mine only cost me $250 US, it turned out to be a real treasure. I would not turn up my nose if another came my way.
I had one, and it was a pretty good sax, and felt good under the fingers. However, it suffered the worst corrosion of any sax I have ever known.
 
Student Yamaha saxes are not made in China, they're made in Indonesia. I have played several, and their quality is on the same level as the Japanese made ones.
That's what I thought, but they are now made in China albeit with stringent Yamaha QC.
Try the Amati, but also try a Yamaha.
As for Jupiter, I had a 500 Series alto and it was OK but nothing special. The 767 altos I have currently are better built and have a decent tone. For these reasons I'd pass over that 500 tenor in favour of a Yamaha.
Buffet 100 and 400 models could be made in China or Germany. I suspect the 400 has parts made at Buffet's Keilwerth factory in Germany.
 
Is not so much about “who” or “where” a saxophone is made. It’s more "how" it was made.

Today I think most new student saxes are made in P.R.C (China). Big companies (brandholders) have good/better QC programs and they are just not buying a container of saxes. It’s still possible to buy blanks and to sell saxes with a brand name.

Travor James Classic II, C.G. Conn TS 650, Jupiter JTS 500, Buffet 100 … are pretty close and are singing with a modern saxophone voice. Good or bad? If you are going to buy one of these make sure you have a saxophone technician so you can have your horn adjusted/service/repaired.

Used or new? Used Yamaha 23, 25 275 280 are good student saxes. The Yamaha 21 is also good but I have seen some of these with problems with the body-bow connection (detachable). Yamaha 23, 25, 275, 280 have glued (soldered?) body-bow and bow-bell. Yamaha is easy to own because most techs are familiar with them. If you are buying a used student saxophone from a private seller, I think you should service (dismantle, clean, oiling, replace some pads, felt and corks (if necessary), assemble, adjust key heights and check key action and ev leaks).

Keilwerth ST 90 are good student saxes as well. The first version was entirely made in Germany and after some years Amati was involved. But still very good student saxes. The last last version was made by KHS Musical Instruments Co., Ltd., Taiwan for Keilwerth company. Not bad, but different.

I was close to buying a mint Bundy II tenor. Just 2400.00 s e k! Still a popular sax among blues- and rock sax players. The Bundy II has a bad reputation among sax players.
 
Mathews music or saxofoonwinkel. Then there is tue rest of europe. I always buy used from a reputable dealer. In the long run you can get way more for your euro. Quality Horns last a lifetime if maintained. Mine is as old as me and it will outlive me.
 
Mathews music or saxofoonwinkel. Then there is tue rest of europe. I always buy used from a reputable dealer. In the long run you can get way more for your euro. Quality Horns last a lifetime if maintained. Mine is as old as me and it will outlive me.
Then you're not playing it hard enough.
As a young lady once said to me 'If you can't take it with you, wear it out'.
 
That's what I thought, but they are now made in China albeit with stringent Yamaha QC.
Hi David, is there a definitive source for this? I've seen various bits of web chatter about where they are made, but can't find anything authorititive, can't find any images that say 'Made in China' and retailers are still saying they're made in Indonesia. Maybe they're made both in Indonesia and China?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom