Mouthpieces Mouthpiece opinions...

Roger, I can't say that I understand Ron's justification, but I guess you can admire his integrity in passing up the quick sale.

For the price of one of his pieces, you could buy four or five different mouthpieces off the E-bay to try out.

I've tried em all over the years, and never have really figured out why some I like and some I don't.

For my old alto, I've currently got in the drawer a metal Link, a metal Brancher, a Jody Jazz with the metal insert thingie and an RPC. But I mostly use a beat up cheap Runyon mouthpiece on it cause it's just easier to play and control under stage conditions. I did some studio work recently and used the RPC on some of it, and the RPC produced a much better sound, but still was harder to control. I guess I'm just not that good of an altoist.

On my tenor, I've tried every thing, and the RPCs were all head and shoulders above the rest. (Occasionally you see RPC's for sale on E-bay, BTW).

If you want to persue it, as has been stated before, you probably want to look for some mouthpieces that are a little more open in the tip. This may mean getting some softer reeds, too.

Jody Jazz
makes a pretty nice looking rubber piece that is being marketed to school programs. It's not a baffled mouthpiece, but I'll bet it sounds good. Sure looks good. They call it their HR (hard rubber) model.


Warning: You are about to embark on the quest for the perfect mouthpiece, a venture that has driven many a saxman to the brink of insanity and beyond. Proceed with caution! :w00t:
 
Just one random question about RPCs....

I guess Ron decided to change colors on his mouthpieces? From everything I read about people talk about the Red Lettering (RPC) on the side but mines blue...?

BTW Lee, ever sense I pulled my 90R outta the package it's been easy to play on...I tried the ligature that came with it but when I switched to Vandoren Optimum it was much more easier...Funny outta the 10 or so mouthpieces I do have this is the first mouthpiece my parents actually came up to me saying they like this tone l.l
 
Warning: You are about to embark on the quest for the perfect mouthpiece, a venture that has driven many a saxman to the brink of insanity and beyond. Proceed with caution! :w00t:

Been there, gone beyond, survived...
 
My philosophy in such situations is either:
1. to become an expert and make up my own mind (not practical with mpcs, at my age 😀 ), or
2. ask the advice of a person you trust and FOLLOW IT 🙂

Course 2 took me from Pete who recommended Ron Coelho and thence to Julian at Saxophones UK.
There was a slight hiccup at that point , as Ron had suggested an Otto Link or, better, a Meyer #6.

Meyers are, from UK, more money than I wanted to spend (for an 'intermediate' mpc), and, anyway, Julian discussed my preferred 'sound' and advised me that a Selmer S80 would probably suit me better than either.

The final recommendation may not be the 'best', but I'm confident that it will not be 'wrong'..... we shall see.

I will stick with it, at least until 'the Fall' 🙂
Now I need to pick suitable reeds :erm:

Oh, and Rule No3 is that, having made your choice, you ignore all the teeth-suckers and head-shakers who say you've made a biiiig mistake!
It's also advisable to read forums such as this with that 'doubting' part of your mind firmly under control.
 
There are many, many out there. IT's kind of fun to buy em on E-bay, then sell em on E-bay if you don't likee. You do have to develop a suitable sterlization regime, though. They're small and easy to ship, so are really ideal for the E-bay universe.

There are also a lot of old ones of different styles out there, and several guys who can take them, open em up and pour a steep baffle, etc. So the possibilities are endless.

Add that to the fact that every horn seems to play better with a different mouthpiece setup (YMMV), and you have the makings for infinite hair pulling.
 
You are certainly right, Lee.

My quest for the perfect mouthpiece has been governed a lot by cost, both in itself and as a proportion of the amount I spent on buying the saxophone itself.

When my alto was my only horn, I lavished many ebay specials on it (good for experimenting relatively cheaply), and have stuck basically with the Selmer Soloist which I suppose in terms of cost is an 'intermediate' mpc but does me fine. Similarly, I bought a new Selmer Soloist for my tenor, although the plastic Yamaha works ok too. I am more than happy with a 4c on my soprano.

Like Roger says, no matter what you buy it's going to be sneered at by some 'purist', but it's your sound so go with what is right for you.

Cheers, Bob
 
Unlike some other pastimes, selecting sax-playing components is such an 'inexact science' that it is, IMO, very difficult to be a 'purist', anyway.

There is no generally-recognised 'best' sax (MkVI, maybe?), OR mouthpiece, OR reed......, so it's just a case of 'If it works for You, it's Right!' 🙂

You CAN, I think, say that you'd be unwise, as a beginner , to try playing a mpc with the same tip-opening/reed-strength as someone who's played for years, but there are probably one or two who could get away with it.
(And there are probably several old-stagers out there happily playing on what many would describe as a 'beginners set-up'!)
 
Roger, I think you'll find the mouthpiece tip openings run the full gamut from small to extremely large. I don't think anybody suggested you go to one that was way big. I believe it was merely surmised that yours probably was too small to produce enough volume and responsiveness, as are many "beginner" mouthpieces. But on reflection that may not even be true in your case.

Maybe Hanson could tell you exactly what you've got and how they matched your mouthpiece to your horn. It may be very well matched, for all I know. They also may have something a bit more open for just a couple bucks.

BTW, the really wide tip openings generally allow the player to use way softer reeds. The pros who are using the #5 reeds are usually playing relatively narrow-tipped mouthpieces. At least, that's been my observation.
 
IMO narrow tip = less pitchbendability.

Some people think fatter reeds = louder, I'm not so sure. If you work at good diaphragm you can get as much volume from softer reeds.

Tip opening can help volume, but also length of lay (the curve) comes into the equation so it's not straightforward.

beware: it's only my opinion.
 
I t ink I'll stick with what I use now i.e. Selmer C* & D, with 2 or 2.5 reeds - I like the amount of pitch-bend I can get, and it's plenty loud!

Is there information anywhere about relative sizes of tip, lay etc for different manufacturers pieces, as they don't seem to use an 'industry standard' system?
 
At 3:23:43 PM 29/06/06, Lee wrote:
Roger, I think you'll find the mouthpiece tip openings run the full gamut from small to extremely large. I don't think anybody suggested you go to one that was way big. I believe it was merely surmised that yours probably was too small to produce enough volume and responsiveness, as are many "beginner" mouthpieces. But on reflection that may not even be true in your case.

Maybe Hanson could tell you exactly what you've got and how they matched your mouthpiece to your horn. It may be very well matched, for all I know. They also may have something a bit more open for just a couple bucks.

Lee, although I don't wish to make any sort of issue of it, I am slightly puzzled by your first two sentences, as I don't think I wrote anything to suggest that I am unaware of this, and thought I needed a much wider tip.

My original equipment ESM certainly has a very small tip opening, as Ken has verified, and he also says he's had good results with a slightly more open Otto Link. (His Hanson alto is, effectively, the same as to mine... apart from the silver-plate!).

So I just thought I'd give a slightly more open mpc a try.
(I can always return to the ESM and/or trawl ebay if I don't get on with it, althought that is NOT my intention 🙂 )

I may well, however, follow your advice and have a chat with Hanson..Thanks.
 
QUOTE:The way (I'm told) to determine the difference between a "no brander" and an "un-badged ESM" is one shows signs of moulding seams.UNQUOTE

OK; but which is which?
Mine is unmarked and very smooth, no signs of moulding seams.
 
Thanks, Ken.
So it appears that my mpc is 'of unknown origin' 😉
I had inferred, wrongly it sounds, that ESMs were the 'standard equipment' on SA-5s.

I can't ask Alastair, (yet) as he's in China!

Not that it really matters, it appears to be well-made and I can make some sort of racket with it! And I'm 'moving-on', anyway.

My Selmer was dispatched 2 days ago, so I hope to have it on Monday (But this IS Spain, and Correos is ..... 🙁 )
 
Hi Ken. Yes, my Otto Link is a Tone Edge too, like I say has a nice sound but doesn't seem as loud as a Meyer or Selmer, wondered if yours was the same...?

Cornwall, a.k.a. my spiritual home, is as gorgeous as ever, and the area around Praa Sands has been occasionally echoing to the sound of a Yamaha YAS62!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,304
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom