Tech/maintenance Middle D intonation

Ok, so those are subtones! I always thought that was some kind of reverb πŸ˜€ Tried today during practice, thought I could get it out but on hearing my playback, probably not.

In any case, I was using the vandoren 2.5 (my one and only good vandoren 2.5 reed) and with this reed seemed to be able to get a better intonation between C# to D, versus the legere (???) - not as stuffy and sounds better. Comparing the palm key vs octave keys they're pretty close I'll have to give the legere a closer look next practice - maybe it's time to revisit cane again. Downsides were.... squeaking, and jumping to the next register on certain keys, and issues playing high E. F and F#. Ah reeds, hate 'em, but can't live without 'em.
 
I haven't found a plastic reed yet that I could live with on a full-time basis. I've tried 'em all, from the earyliest ones in the 1960's right up to the latest offerings from Legere. None of hem have the tonal quality ofr response of a cane reed. I use a Legere on my clarinet though when playing big band stuff, becasue it sits for as much as several hours, and then I have to grab and play it in a hurry. It's OK for that, but even then, I don't particularly like the tonal quality. I realize it doesn't help matters any that the only short barrel (60mm) that I own is an aluminum Acubore. But, here again, it is a matter of grabbing the horn cold, and having it play, and be in tune. (I have a Buffet barrell that I turned down to 58mm, because I was working a long-term gig in a theater where they kept the piano tuned about 30 cents high, but it is too short to hit an A-440, even when the instrument is completely cold.) For theater work, though, I stick with my 64mm Moenning barrel and a cane reed. (The clarinet is a mid-1950's Buffet - from before the days of the R-13, but equivalent to one.)
 
Downsides were.... squeaking, and jumping to the next register on certain keys, and issues playing high E. F and F#. Ah reeds, hate 'em, but can't live without 'em.[/QUOTE]

Hi Alvin,
At this stage of your development, I think you should be concentrating on the lower end of the instrument rather than high F#. The fact that you mention this note and your dislike of cane reeds, gives the game away as to the why you are having problems.

John.
 
@picconose: I agree with your thoughts - the good cane reeds I've tried definitely do sound better to my ear.

@John: Why does a dislike of cane give problems? From my point of view as a raw beginner, synthetics give me the confidence to pick up my instrument and play a low Bb to high F. Confidently, if not in perfect intonation.
 
@John: Why does a dislike of cane give problems? From my point of view as a raw beginner, synthetics give me the confidence to pick up my instrument and play a low Bb to high F. Confidently, if not in perfect intonation.[/QUOTE]

Because of the downsides you mentioned. A good reed (and I think a 2.5 might be a little to hard for you), suitably prepared, should give no problems. The thought I have, is that you are fighting the reed which is causing you to blow too hard. Hence the squeaks and other probs.

John.
 
Hi Alvin,

Last night I suddenly remembered that when I was having this problem that I played a harder reed.

I really think this is an embouchure problem as it needs to be very relaxed when playing middle D. What I fdid was to play a harder reed (about 1/2 strength more) than my normal one for about a week seemed to help me control my embouchure more. When I finally went back to my normal strength reed the note was played cleanly and within 5 cent.

Hope it helps a bit!
 
Hey Paul, thanks for the tip!
I have a legere 2.75 and vandoren #3 on standby here ;-) Will take me a much longer time though, I remember one of your weeks consist of 6 (or more?) practice hours a day? I only do about 6 a week ;-)

Oh, in other news, my JP043C curved soprano has finally arrived! Woot! Fitted with a plasticover 2.5 and B7 graftonite, it is amazingly in tune, even middle D works very well and not too stuffy (!?). Can't go higher than high C atm, and anything below low D has a tendency to jump registers, unless I blow really, really carefully or slur down. Back on the alto tomorrow :3

Alvin
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom