Playing the saxophone Jazz players and rock & roll players

Well not really. I think the problem comes when you try to define the origins of rock and roll, which is generally claimed to be around 1950 (claims being made for Bill Haley, Fats Domino and Elvis etc.)

But the "origins" are from at least a decade earlier with Jump Blues and Swing. So as those genres included both jazz and blues players as well as those who did both it's going to be a never ending argument probably 🙂

Bullmoose Jackson vs Illinois Jacquet I suppose.
The early R&B honkers were in my opinion not Rock & Roll. Good players but I think it's wrong to give them "Rock & Roll" label. But it's hard to draw the line. You have to do that yourself! Listen to recordings ..... .
 
Some CD compilations and R&B honking. Many, many ..... more recordings on internet. From the wildest Chuck Higgins, Joe Houston, Big Jay McNeely ..... to balladers like Lynn Hope and Tab Smith .... The singing saxplayers like Bullmoose Jackson and Cleanhead Vinson .... easy listening music aimed for radio and jukeboxes .....
cdsax.JPGRnBett.JPGRnBfyra.JPGRnBtre.JPG
 
Last edited:
Somehow off topic ...
I was asked by my band to play RnR sax .... The songs I have to perform have a "nasty" "growly" tone and aggressive altissimo ....
The first attempts were dissapointing.
My embouchoure .... my tone .... my breath support .... they all failed to simulate what I'm supposed to do.
I'm cheating by using a more specialized Berg style mouthpiece that helps a lot .... but I need a lot of work.

RnR sax is a whole different way of playing ... it's a special genre in it's self. .....
Everyone expects from you to move up and down ( all my life I play still in a "correct" Alexander technique compliant position ) , have a blasting tone without overblowing .... ( ouch ) ..... and groul 24/7/365 ( oh lord ... the hrrrrrr technique made my neck sore ... and the vocal technique needs to think what is the pitch of the note I'm playing in contrast to the own I'm humming ... oh lord... lol )

Great respect to the true RnR sax performers out there.
 
lord ... the hrrrrrr technique made my neck sore
That is fluttertongue not growl and best to be kept for occasional effects
the vocal technique needs to think what is the pitch of the note I'm playing in contrast
Singing specific pitches doesn’t work for me, I find trial and error is best. It’s also much easier.
 
Last edited:
Somehow off topic ...
I was asked by my band to play RnR sax .... The songs I have to perform have a "nasty" "growly" tone and aggressive altissimo ....
The first attempts were dissapointing.
My embouchoure .... my tone .... my breath support .... they all failed to simulate what I'm supposed to do.
I'm cheating by using a more specialized Berg style mouthpiece that helps a lot .... but I need a lot of work.

RnR sax is a whole different way of playing ... it's a special genre in it's self. .....
Everyone expects from you to move up and down ( all my life I play still in a "correct" Alexander technique compliant position ) , have a blasting tone without overblowing .... ( ouch ) ..... and groul 24/7/365 ( oh lord ... the hrrrrrr technique made my neck sore ... and the vocal technique needs to think what is the pitch of the note I'm playing in contrast to the own I'm humming ... oh lord... lol )

Great respect to the true RnR sax performers out there.
Don’t worry, it is v different to the jazz and classical stuff I spent my formative years playing and I found (still find) it the most difficult gig. It’s v physical as you say, and yes, you go toe to toe with screaming singers and wailing guitars. Many rock guys play extreme altissimo (above D) yet few of the jazz guys do (apart from Brandon Fields and Marc Russo maybe).
It’s “simpler” music - but boy it’s big on what you have to say. It has my respect!
 
I've been living (honking, listening, reading, ...) with Rock & Roll Saxophone for 54 years so I don't know any other style. I don't play jazz, classical ..... and if anyone ask me to play with a jazz band I would turn it down. Simply not good enough. I play on a low level.
 
Well, I'm not strictly RockSax. I have been playing/rehearsal with an orchestra that is not playing jazz, rock ...... they are are just playing. An orchestra that was formed in late 30's as a school orchestra and today they are really struggling to survive. I'm 68 and I reduce the average age!!!
 
Andy Snitzer is well known as a pop-rock sax player, AND a great jazz player. Rolling Stones, Paul Simon, Billy Joel, Sting … etc. He did an interview with Jay Metcalf (Better Sax) that came out today, and he discusses the (false) dichotomy between jazz and rock playing, in some depth. Worth a look.
View: https://youtu.be/zcNuWTyelgI?si=S454tt7nT5OZ52d_
I’ve been a fan of Snitzer since the 90’s. Usually gets a load of tumbleweed if I ever mention him on here.
 
Yes there are many sax players that can play jazz, rock & roll .... even classical music. For me the true rock & roll sax player is a permanent member of a band. A session player can do a very good rock job in the studio. But there are/were players that often on the road with a band.
 
Last edited:
Andy Snitzer is well known as a pop-rock sax player, AND a great jazz player. Rolling Stones, Paul Simon, Billy Joel, Sting … etc. He did an interview with Jay Metcalf (Better Sax) that came out today, and he discusses the (false) dichotomy between jazz and rock playing, in some depth. Worth a look.
View: https://youtu.be/zcNuWTyelgI?si=S454tt7nT5OZ52d_
He actually discusses the differences in detail and how you need to go about approaching what is demanded.

I recently saw a similar interview with Brandon Fields - he also came from a pop background.

He does talk about an extreme (Johnny Hodges) being a bridge too far. I think that in parts of this thread (types of) rock n roll are also an extreme, and playing without a growl etc is not really getting there.

It works both ways too, I know someone who won’t entertain Brecker as being a jazz player - “he’s a rock player” - go figure, but..

The bandwidth within styles varies enormously, and sometimes it has to be one type of thing only.
It does exist in jazz - G Miller for one, in which you could be off the bandstand in record time if you don’t play “as is”.

I emailed Andy back in the 90’s (no idea where I found his email address, probably on an album sleeve) and he replied. I asked him about the “undertone” sound he gets, particularly on A and G just above the stave. Super nice guy, he emailed back. I spoke with him a few more times via email over the next several years, always v approachable. Must have lots more email traffic these days though, and the social media thing too.
 
Playing rocksax changed over the years. Today players are playing with more modern sax voice. "- With that saxophone and set-up you sound like a combo of an old-time honker and Clarence Clemons. You are not playing in a modern style." Good or bad? It made my day.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom