Ah - this is the anti early music viewpoint interview that sparked a pile of comment elsewhere. I can strongly recommend avoiding Shenkerian analysis unless you want a headache.
As someone who falls into the early music camp, I'll add my two pen'orth.
First of all, I'm not keen on absolutes. One of the really big issues with performance of any music before the invention of recording (say 1900) is that we have no idea what it really sounded like. We can make some educated assumptions. Musicology (history of music and of performance styles) was not a serious subject until late in the C19th. Prior to that we have people writing things down from time to time. We don't know if these people were muscians, if they knew what they were talking about, accurately described things, whether what they describe was standard practice etc etc.
The original purpose of vibrato was as a form of decoration (an affect) on longer notes, usually in slow pieces. Sometime during late C19th or C20th vibrato became "continuous" vibrato. Singers adopted it because it helps the sound to carry over a big orchestra (think horned helmets, Brunhilde, and a Wagner sized orchestra. It's totally wrong for Mozart, Beethoven etc.
Equally, Mozart and Haydn wrote for an orchestra with typically 2222 woodwind (2 each flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon), 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timps and strings of about 66421 (6 1st and 2nd violin, 4 viola, 2 celli, 1 bass). So performing that with a Tchaikovsky symphony string department of strings (14 14 12 10 6) just doesn't feel right (it changes the perceived sound quite a lot).
Haydn or Mozart played by a chamber orchestra such as ASMF on modern instruments, or a period instrument group, both work. But I like the older instruments as they have a better balance. Here's a simple example:
In Elgar's scores, he often asks for the trombones (there's usually 3 - alto, tenor, bass) to play FFF i.e. very loud. Most conductors cut this back to FF. Why? It's quite simple, a trombone from around 1900 has a much smaller bore and a smaller bell than a modern instrument. Modern instruments are MUCH louder than older ones.