Tutorials
Shop
Youtube
|
Bluesky
|
acebook
Supporting special needs music education since 2008
About
Café fundraising
📣 Advertise
Mailing
Pete Thomas music
Biog
?
Rules, terms, privacy
Forum help (guide)
Tech support forum
Discussion
All forum sections
Start a discussion
Reviews (feed)
Articles
Articles on the Cafe
Articles on Taming The Saxophone
Shop
NEW
Log in
Register
What's new
All forum sections
Start a discussion
Reviews (feed)
Menu
Log in
Register
How to install the app
How to install the app on iOS
NB: For Safari start at step 2
(Firefox only) Tap on the hamburger menu at bottom right
Tap on the share icon
(bottom of page)
Scroll down and tap on
Add to Home Screen:
Note:
This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Discussion
Main Discussion sections
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Improvisation or copying?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Wade Cornell" data-source="post: 61857" data-attributes="member: 1787"><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">Rudjarl has a very valid question that is more philosophical than mathematical. In my opinion looking strictly at mechanical aspect of playing denies the essence of music. It’s not just notes, how many, or the number of ways they can be combined. As in all the arts it’s about communication. This comes about through subtleties of expression and basically having something to “say”.</span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'"> </span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">Once sufficiently experienced each of us can play the same notes as (name your favourite player or a track of theirs), but does it sound the same? Even if you could imitate that person exactly what would be the point? What makes good or great art is that spark that comes from within an individual, not the person who tries to copy it exactly.</span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'"> </span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">We each have our own voice and own stories to tell. Too many approach playing an instrument or any of the other arts as a mechanical exercise. Well, yes, there is that aspect, but that’s just learning to use the tools and vocabulary for expression and not necessarily an end to itself. </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">Jazz has been codified to a great extent which I guess is an aid to teaching, but I have some doubts about whether this is ultimately helping or hindering a potential player who wants to make a living out of music and contribute to its future. What’s the market for mainstream (50s and 60s sounding) jazz players? Is this a good way to teach basics, well maybe, but that brings to mind a famous quote about forgetting everything you learned and just playing. </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">The sax is probably the closest instrument to the human voice, which gives us a potential advantage over instruments like a piano. We can “voice” our notes within a huge range of possibilities (that alone blows out all the mathematics). Timbre, pitch, attack, decay, vibrato, slurs, etc. are all there to be used. This gives us the ability to deliver something way beyond 12 notes. </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">I hear rudjarl's frustration and longing to see if there is somewhere else to go. Is jazz music just mechanical learning in which you memorize forms then cut and paste as appropriate? I don’t think it needs to be, but you’ve got to engage in a much more emotional and personal way that’s not just finger memory (learned licks and arpeggios). This means stepping outside of simply “playing the changes” and thinking personally about the music.</span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'"> </span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">Lest be realistic, not everybody is going to be a great artist no matter how hard they try or study, but you need to grow beyond the mechanical/learning aspects and move towards having something unique or your own to say. Without taking that step you are nothing more than a technician or copyist. </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">As a newbie on this site I don’t know how much has been said about ear training or singing practice. If a lot, then you probably already know what’s coming: You can’t expect anything profound, artistic, or unique to come out of your horn unless you can hear it in your head first (this isn’t about happy one off accidents). Learning patterns for wiggling your fingers and making intellectually predictable noises (without knowing the sound first) isn’t being a creative musician. </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">Can you sing a simple tune (“happy birthday to you”, for example) and then play it in all keys? Being able to be one with your instrument so that it becomes your voice should be the goal. Whatever you can hear you should be able to play. That should be plenty challenge for most, and can take you a long way as a musician and performer. </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">The next step is to have the music in your head that you will play. This can be a very large library of music you know and grab bits and pieces from, or you could be one of those blessed with true creativity.</span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">The last step that brings it together is that your playing is an honest expression. Well, honest in the same way that an actor has the skill of acting or making the lines believable and delivered with integrity. This is where you go way beyond notes and are using all of the appropriate nuances to deliver the emotions and feeling which are appropriate to the music. </span></p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">The whole package comes back to communication. When you play a piece where is the art? Is it in the notes on the page and you just sound the right tone at the right time? Is it in cutting and pasting together a bunch of riffs and arpeggios that just happen to be in the right chord/mode? </span></p><p> </p><p><span style="font-family: 'Tahoma'">Once you know your way around your instrument I think it’s about making it your voice and saying whatever it is you are capable of. </span></p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Wade Cornell, post: 61857, member: 1787"] [FONT=Tahoma]Rudjarl has a very valid question that is more philosophical than mathematical. In my opinion looking strictly at mechanical aspect of playing denies the essence of music. It’s not just notes, how many, or the number of ways they can be combined. As in all the arts it’s about communication. This comes about through subtleties of expression and basically having something to “say”.[/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]Once sufficiently experienced each of us can play the same notes as (name your favourite player or a track of theirs), but does it sound the same? Even if you could imitate that person exactly what would be the point? What makes good or great art is that spark that comes from within an individual, not the person who tries to copy it exactly.[/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]We each have our own voice and own stories to tell. Too many approach playing an instrument or any of the other arts as a mechanical exercise. Well, yes, there is that aspect, but that’s just learning to use the tools and vocabulary for expression and not necessarily an end to itself. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]Jazz has been codified to a great extent which I guess is an aid to teaching, but I have some doubts about whether this is ultimately helping or hindering a potential player who wants to make a living out of music and contribute to its future. What’s the market for mainstream (50s and 60s sounding) jazz players? Is this a good way to teach basics, well maybe, but that brings to mind a famous quote about forgetting everything you learned and just playing. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]The sax is probably the closest instrument to the human voice, which gives us a potential advantage over instruments like a piano. We can “voice” our notes within a huge range of possibilities (that alone blows out all the mathematics). Timbre, pitch, attack, decay, vibrato, slurs, etc. are all there to be used. This gives us the ability to deliver something way beyond 12 notes. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]I hear rudjarl's frustration and longing to see if there is somewhere else to go. Is jazz music just mechanical learning in which you memorize forms then cut and paste as appropriate? I don’t think it needs to be, but you’ve got to engage in a much more emotional and personal way that’s not just finger memory (learned licks and arpeggios). This means stepping outside of simply “playing the changes” and thinking personally about the music.[/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]Lest be realistic, not everybody is going to be a great artist no matter how hard they try or study, but you need to grow beyond the mechanical/learning aspects and move towards having something unique or your own to say. Without taking that step you are nothing more than a technician or copyist. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]As a newbie on this site I don’t know how much has been said about ear training or singing practice. If a lot, then you probably already know what’s coming: You can’t expect anything profound, artistic, or unique to come out of your horn unless you can hear it in your head first (this isn’t about happy one off accidents). Learning patterns for wiggling your fingers and making intellectually predictable noises (without knowing the sound first) isn’t being a creative musician. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]Can you sing a simple tune (“happy birthday to you”, for example) and then play it in all keys? Being able to be one with your instrument so that it becomes your voice should be the goal. Whatever you can hear you should be able to play. That should be plenty challenge for most, and can take you a long way as a musician and performer. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma][/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]The next step is to have the music in your head that you will play. This can be a very large library of music you know and grab bits and pieces from, or you could be one of those blessed with true creativity.[/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma][/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]The last step that brings it together is that your playing is an honest expression. Well, honest in the same way that an actor has the skill of acting or making the lines believable and delivered with integrity. This is where you go way beyond notes and are using all of the appropriate nuances to deliver the emotions and feeling which are appropriate to the music. [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]The whole package comes back to communication. When you play a piece where is the art? Is it in the notes on the page and you just sound the right tone at the right time? Is it in cutting and pasting together a bunch of riffs and arpeggios that just happen to be in the right chord/mode? [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma] [/FONT] [FONT=Tahoma]Once you know your way around your instrument I think it’s about making it your voice and saying whatever it is you are capable of. [/FONT] [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
Join us in the Cafe!
Social
New! Social Feeds
Look out for the navigation icon:
Follow CafeSaxophone
Foroverse
Youtube
Bluesky
Facebook
Latest Song of the Month
SOTM
November 26 SOTM - Footprints - Wayne Shorter
Started by sax panther
Nov 1, 2026
Replies: 11
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
T
SOTM
SOTM October 2026 - The Chicken
Started by Taragot
Sep 30, 2026
Replies: 18
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SotM September 2026 - Autumn Leaves
Started by mrblackbat
Sep 1, 2026
Replies: 27
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM August 2026 - Creep
Started by atwl77
Jul 31, 2026
Replies: 13
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
and Play by ear July 2026
Started by Wade Cornell
Jun 30, 2026
Replies: 21
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM June 2026 "And You Just Smile" (from ear to ear- training)
Started by LostCircuits
May 30, 2026
Replies: 11
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM May 2026 - Always Remember Us This Way
Started by MikeMorrell
Apr 28, 2026
Replies: 39
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM April 2026 - Freedom Jazz Dance
Started by rhysonsax
Mar 31, 2026
Replies: 14
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM and PETE (Play by Ear Training Exercise)
Started by Wade Cornell
Feb 28, 2026
Replies: 16
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM Feb 2026 - On Green Dolphin Street
Started by mrblackbat
Jan 31, 2026
Replies: 44
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM January 2026: Our Love Is Here to Stay
Started by GCinCT
Jan 1, 2026
Replies: 46
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
SOTM
SOTM December 2025: Wexford Carol
Started by MikeMorrell
Nov 30, 2025
Replies: 37
Cafe Members' Recordings & Gigs
Member Blogs (currently active)
Saxophones
Pork Tales: Saxophone Repair DIY Adventures.
Started by PigSquealer
May 22, 2025
Replies: 1K
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Blog
Tenor Viol's musings
Started by Tenor Viol
Oct 22, 2016
Replies: 2K
☕️ Breakfastroom (chat and relax...) ☕️
Blog
Mike's musings
Started by MikeMorrell
Sep 5, 2024
Replies: 296
☕️ Breakfastroom (chat and relax...) ☕️
Trending
Pork Tales: Saxophone Repair DIY Adventures.
PigSquealer
May 22, 2025
Replies: 1K
Daily Check In
Jeanette
Apr 21, 2024
Replies: 3K
H
The Alphabet of Tone
Hassles
Nov 15, 2026
Replies: 124
Low Bb vs low A baritones.
Pete Thomas
Oct 29, 2026
Replies: 197
Tenor Viol's musings
Tenor Viol
Oct 22, 2016
Replies: 2K
S
What are you listening to (plus reviews)
suethesax
Nov 18, 2007
Replies: 3K
Do we really need theory?
jbtsax
Feb 18, 2016
Replies: 507
L
Alto for warm tone
LisaP2026
Nov 14, 2026
Replies: 75
The Cafe Trio grown to Octet down to Sextet
trimmy
Feb 15, 2015
Replies: 846
Learn to play by ear or by reading music
Taz
Feb 16, 2016
Replies: 1K
Popular Discussions
Great Players
Who sparked your love of Sax music
Started by jools
Apr 2, 2008
Replies: 630
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Playing the saxophone
The Cafe Trio grown to Octet down to Sextet
Started by trimmy
Feb 15, 2015
Replies: 846
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Theory & Impro
Do we really need theory?
Started by jbtsax
Feb 18, 2016
Replies: 507
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Saxophones
C Melody Saxophones
Started by Andy Hornblower
Aug 19, 2015
Replies: 706
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Saxophones
Carrying a tenor on a (motor)bike?
Started by Jay
Jul 4, 2015
Replies: 741
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Saxophones
How will Tariffs affect Sax Prices?
Started by Ivan
Apr 4, 2025
Replies: 465
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Jazz
Music for Night Owls
Started by saxplorer
Mar 5, 2015
Replies: 466
Great music and favourite Videos
Playing the saxophone
Learn to play by ear or by reading music
Started by Taz
Feb 16, 2016
Replies: 1K
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Tech/maintenance
My new "DIY" pads...
Started by DavidUK
Jan 12, 2022
Replies: 393
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
6
Misc Reviews
Yamaha YDS-150 Wind Synth
Started by Acc6441
Oct 22, 2020
Replies: 301
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Forum statistics
Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Discussion
Main Discussion sections
🎷 Saxophones: gear, playing, repair, impro 🎷
Improvisation or copying?
Back
Top
Bottom