Playing the saxophone How do You Play This?

I asked a friend "....... can be a software mistake. If the person who made this chart was using Finale that low note could have assigned to the sax part by mistake due to settings in Finale." ????

Maybe you have already solve the mystery?
 
Well, as Lydian suggested, I finallly actually LISTENED to the passage. It's a clear flutter tongue or possibly a very strong growl, that creates the upper octave harmonic. For me the correct way to notate would indicate this - maybe a note "FT" and the trill sign, or something like that. If you care enough about this one throwaway note in a brief pop solo, you could indicate with an X note head or a diamond note head the upper harmonic A. Blowing hard, flutter tonguing a low D for just an instant, it'd be hard NOT to have the thing go a bit multiphonic.
 
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHzVjGBxOJs

Solo starts 1:38, flutter tongue at 1:52. Transcriber is confusing the bass with a multiphonic on bari. It's not a multiphonic, and is notated wrong.

As I answered before on how to play, just flutter tongue.
Now Im confused, that sounds like a completely different solo as it seems to be baritone and it's nothing like what is written, it seems to be held for 3 1/4 notes (dotted half). Also OP says it's the tenor solo.

But yes that but is a growl flutter tongue not a harmonic 1/16 as notated on the PDF
 
Your guess is as good as mine. I listened for the only special effect in the solo on the record. I didn’t look at the transcription. If it’s of a different solo, the OP will need to post the correct recording.
 
First solo is baritone. Tenor solo starts at about 3.50.
Yes that's what I'm hearing and within the (later) tenor solo I haven't identified the notated note/s and rhythm which is why I asked for the recording with time stamp of the bit we need.

I listened for the only special effect in the solo on the record.
You are correct that was a special effect on the baritone solo, but fluttertongue should be notated as such, not with the typical diamond notehead you get with harmonics notation.
 
Hmm, could be the figure at 3:26-27. Goes by pretty quick (~80 ms, less than the blink of an eye). Sounds like he simply missed the A. If I had to play this, I would just skip that effect entirely since it sounds like a mistake.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom