Helping the Recording Engineer to Record Saxophones

rhysonsax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,417
Location
Surrey, UK
It looks like the seven piece covers band I play in are going to venture into the studio in the next few weeks to record a few demo tracks. I'm the one man horn section and want to sound as good as I can.

Last time we did this, although we were in a decent pro studio, the engineer had never recorded wind instruments before and didn't know what to do about choice of mic, placement, effects, mixing the sax tracks with the rest of the band. As a result my sax parts sound like they were played by an idiot using the kazoo/sax setting on an electronic keyboard costing less than a fiver.

I was pretty depressed to say the least. Then my sax teacher recorded me playing on his own set-up in his favourite room and with his preferred effects. That sounds much, much better and it left me cursing the studio engineer.

Any tips for doing it better this time, just in case we get another inexperienced engineer ?

Thanks in advance

Rhys

PS Sax teacher has since emigrated to Oz to get away from me, so I can't ask him.
 
rhysonsax wrote:
Last time we did this, although we were in a decent pro studio, the engineer had never recorded wind instruments before and didn't know what to do about choice of mic, placement, effects, mixing the sax tracks with the rest of the band.

In which case it wasn't a decent pro studio. Have you discussed with with the rest of the band?
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
In which case it wasn't a decent pro studio. Have you discussed with with the rest of the band?

I just meant that the facilities and equipment were professional. The engineer working with us was only familiar with rock bands, so knew about mic-ing up, mixing and mastering drums, guitars, keyboards, vocals. He didn't know about mic selection and placement and effects etc for saxes, horns or presumably cellos, flutes or anything else.

The rest of the band were aware of it at the time and I will certainly raise the issue again.

What I am after is a bit more knowledge myself, so that I can understand what sort of mic should be used, where, what effects etc...

And while I'm here, I understand about mixing, but what happens in "mastering" ?

Rhys
 
Well if the studio has a good selection of mics, then you certainly won't go wrong with an AKG 414 or the neumann U87, both very common pro studio mics.

As to the mixing, then this is a very long and complex topic. My favorite is to compress the saxophone and a simple but very effective method for me is to use a short (about .9 to 1.2 econd) room simulation te everything, before adding a longer reverb (usually 2 - 2.5 seconds to some other instruments (but not the bass or drums)

Neither the "room" nor reverb need to even be loud enough to actually hear very clearly, often the effect is to just make everything sound natural and together, even if they have been recorded separately or with separation.

I find that the room means you don't need so much of the longer reverb - a lot of reverb can work, but very often its annoying, however the room has a much subtler effect in placing the instruments.

Mastering is a further process and usually done at a dedicated mastering studio. A good mastering engineer will take the finished stereo mix and (hopefully with extremely good monitoring, ears and specialist equipment) make it sound better and louder as well as optimised for whatever medium it is to be distributed on. Some people bypass this stage and send a mix straight from the studio to manufacturing. This is possible, but often they wonder why it doesn't sound as good or as loud as stuff they hear on the radio or other CDs they buy.

re: loudness. It became very popular to make CDs as loud as possible - when played alongside less loud CDs on the radio, the loud ones tend to sound better.

Trouble is that the loudness is done by compressing so much that (a) all dynamics and sense of space are gone and (b) after a while it can make your ears "tired".
 
Afterthought:

To a certain (and usually quite limited) extent, a good mastering engineer can salvage a bad mix.

1) get it right at stage 1 (recording)
2) don't mess it up at stage 2 (mixing
3) mastering puts the icing on the cake.

It's better to have the icing than to have the mastering try to repair everything else. I use a mastering studio in Harlesden called Soundmastering (very good)
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
As to the mixing, then this is a very long and complex topic. My favorite is to compress the saxophone and a simple but very effective method for me is to use a short (about .9 to 1.2 econd) room simulation te everything, before adding a longer reverb (usually 2 - 2.5 seconds to some other instruments (but not the bass or drums)

Thanks Pete. Although I have heard of "compression" and "reverb" I hadn't heard of "room simulation".

How much "compression" is good to use ?

Are you saying that this "room simulation" effect is applied to just the sax or equally to all the instrument tracks ?

I saw from your excellent YouTube recording on the Bauhaus alto that the mic was about 2 to 3 feet away from the sax and slightly up to the right side. That was very much the position my teacher used to record me, so presumably the best place (if there aren't other instruments around).

Rhys
 
How much compression is not possible to say. I can't give a setting like 5dB or 40%. All compressors are different and work on at least two parameters (ratio & threshold but often more e.g. with speed & release) that all interact. It also depends on what is going in.

In other words, the best amount is "a bit", "some" or "a lot".
Sorry.

Room simulation is basically a type of very short reverb, like you hear in an empty reflective small to medium sized room, as opposed to longer reverbs like what people normally call reverb which is the sort of ambience you get in a hall, church, or generated synthetically, e.g. by a plate (these are generally 2 seconds or longer)
 
Hi Rhys,
I chopped your words down to summarise and add my sympathy vote that's all.


rhysonsax wrote:
Last time we did this, although we were in a decent pro studio,
I was pretty depressed to say the least.

I can't say I'm estatic about my recordings with backing tracks but our band have been to studios and I more often than not leave embarrased and frustrated.
This used to knock my confidence about my sound but experience over time has shown me that I can be recorded 'how I here it'.

I face facts now that your guitarist/drummer/singer won't be half as bothered about your sound and sadly, if they are happy with their own sounds and start watching the clock you may not convince the engineer either.
 
Good luck Rhys I hope it goes well for you all.
Will you be posting the finished result if its any good? (it may be interesting to hear even if its not what you were hoping for, you know, sort of educational...in a good sort of way...I think... 8| :? :erm:
 
We had a long day in the studio on 19th October recording 6 varied songs from our repertoire. Rhythm section + guide vocals first and that took about 4 hours.

Sax next, but under pressure to leave enough time for lead vocals, backing vocals and sundry percussion. Altogether I got about 40 minutes for my parts, and some of that was taken up trying different mics, experimenting with mic placement etc. So very little time for alternative takes and none at all for multi-tracking the sax parts. I had wanted some nice fat horn section sounds for a couple of the songs.

It took the recording engineer a couple of weeks to deliver the mixed and mastered songs on CD. I've uploaded mp3 versions of them to the band's website if anyone would like to have a listen.

http://www.thecelebrationband.org/live/

It's interesting that the engineer seems to have given quite different treatment to the sax on different tracks. Some sound quite prominent and some not. Some have a fairly natural sound and others seem to sound more "processed".

An interesting experience, but I would love to have had a lot more time !

Rhys

PS We ended up using a nice dynamic mic for the sax and recorded it close-mic'd. Not sure what different effects were added in the mixing.
 
Hi Rhys, it's good to hear about other peoples experiences in recording saxes. We've just started some recording in our band (trying it ourselves). We invested in a home recording desk (a Boss BR1600) so we can record ourselves and play around with our songs before we spend any money in a studio. It wasn't mega expensive and will hopefully save us some money in the long run. To be honest it's been really useful already as we can hear any bits we especially need to work on in different songs or rethink re. tempo, arrangement so when we go into a studio (hopefully!) we should be able to get straight on and record. But it still made my sax sound like an accordian when we first recorded it. I'm going to let our guitarist (he's the teccie) have a look at Pete's comments and mess around with the desk's compression etc. I'll have a listen to your tracks later tonight Rhys.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,430
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom