Saxophones Help needed with old Saxophones

What do you mean 50 squid was a joke? Yesterday I borrowed the 50 squids for the horns.
 

Attachments

  • Hanging_Squid_1.webp
    Hanging_Squid_1.webp
    10 KB · : 232
Was wondering what the best method of cleaning is? Could go mad with the brasso, but don't want to remove any of the 'lacquer' that I've heard mention of.

Don't.....

Many people like the patina of an old sax, and polishing a bare brass one will reduce it's desirability. I don't agree with it myself, but it's the way it is (fashion?).....

What's the finish on these horns? Is either one gold or silver plated? Or bare brass, or lacquered metal.

If the Buescher is a soprano, as opposed to an alto, it's desirability goes up a lot. Photos will help, but also the length of the body from the neck socket to the brace at the bottom of the bell.
 
Don't.....

Many people like the patina of an old sax, and polishing a bare brass one will reduce it's desirability. I don't agree with it myself, but it's the way it is (fashion?).....

What's the finish on these horns? Is either one gold or silver plated? Or bare brass, or lacquered metal.

If the Buescher is a soprano, as opposed to an alto, it's desirability goes up a lot. Photos will help, but also the length of the body from the neck socket to the brace at the bottom of the bell.

I shall leave polishing it then!!

I would think it could be silver plated as it has a very strong smell of old silver (if that makes sense) but then it could be laquer as you can see a bit of brass where some of the silver colour has rubbed off. The buttons are brass some with mother of pearl inlays. This is the same for both horns. If it were laquer would there be flaking?? these ones just seem slightly tarnished.

The Buesher measures approx 35cm from the neck to bottom, the diameter of the bell is 8cm. We willput picture of it up now.

I so wish we knew more about musical instruments. Have come across a clarinet and violin today, more research ahead of us! The violin label is a Strad but I know we are not that lucky lol!!!
 
'Strad' violins...

Lots of these around, quality can vary from firwood to being a good instrument, many are OK. A lot were made in and around Markneukirchen/Graslitz(Kraslice), which was a major instrument building area before WWII (saxes as well). Although the older ones didn't, the later ones say where they were made (as a result of legal changes). They usually have a label in latin saying it was made by Stradiuarius in Cremonensis (note spelling). A pupil in my daughter's orchestra has one and is convinced he's playing a genuine Strad..... I used to think it was a con by the makers, but if it gives the little darlings an incentive to practice, maybe not.

If you google Stradiuarius or Stradivarius Cremonensis fake you'll find lots of references to these, such as this one:

http://www.fritz-reuter.com/DOC/articles/artiexp1.htm

You won't be surprised to find that many of the web sites have the full text of the label...

Same is also true for other greats in the violin world.

About all you can do with this is to take it to a recognised luthier and get an assessment of it's quality/value before selling. It needs an expert to assess the quality. Wouldn't do any harm to get a second opinion.

Clarinet - should be marked with make at least. This may be stamped into the wood and be difficult to read. Be aware there are quite a few different key/finger systems, although the most likely is that it's a standard Boehm key system. Given the quality of the saxes, it's likely that this is also a top line instrument. And the comments I made about pricng the saxes also apply.
 
Hi Kev

I have uploaded some more photis, hope they help a little more!

Re the Strad, Im not holding my breath, it is very old as it has hardly any varnish etc on it, no srtings, basically just a wooden shell. It also does not have a made in stamp. Like you said if it gives a child an incentive to learn this skill then it can only be good. From what I have read regarding the label it is a very good genuine fake, if there is such a thing ;-)

The clarinet is a Lewin, I can just about make out the stamp on the clarinet plus it is in its original box as are the Saxophones. My Grandad certainly seemed to know his instruments.
 
I shall leave polishing it then!! I would think it could be silver plated as it has a very strong smell of old silver (if that makes sense) but then it could be laquer as you can see a bit of brass where some of the silver colour has rubbed off. The buttons are brass some with mother of pearl inlays. This is the same for both horns. If it were laquer would there be flaking?? these ones just seem slightly tarnished. The Buesher measures approx 35cm from the neck to bottom, the diameter of the bell is 8cm. We willput picture of it up now. I so wish we knew more about musical instruments. Have come across a clarinet and violin today, more research ahead of us! The violin label is a Strad but I know we are not that lucky lol!!!

As Kev says, many makers 'copied' the style of instruments made by great makers such as Stradivarius and others. These makers settled on a design which has not been improved on much in over 300 years.

Most luthiers and the 'factory' system produced isntruments in the 'style' of these great makers.

Some of these instruments are very valuable in their own right as they are well made. Even an early C20th copy from a good maker could be worth thousands (and a bow from a good maker could be worth a lot too).

If the instrument is C19th/early C20th and if made by a half-decent maker German/French/Italian it is likely to be worth quite a bit (even a modest instrument is likely to be worth about £1,000). There are some sought after British makers too. It is difficult to buy a decent early C20th German cello for less than £5,000.

For reference, I have just bought a new Chinese made 'cello. There was a choice of a Strad, Montagnana, Goffriller.

I recommend you see a reputable luthier or dealer. With string instruments, valuations are commonly required for insurance purposes so it is a common request. You may be asked to pay about £50 for a valuation - some dealers have special valuation days when it might be free/reduced. Valuation/evaluation is a very specialist skill.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re the violin, extremely unlikely - many makers perfectly validly produce instruments modelled on Strad or other great makers. My (new) cello is modelled on Montagnana. There are string instrument dealers who will provide a valuation but they usually charge (~ £50 ish probably - this is often done for insurance purposes, so is very common request with stirng instruments).

Don't worry I am fully aware that is very unlikely, like I said to my untrained eye it looks like a very good genuine fake.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom