Reeds Effect of climate, temperature, humidity etc on cane

An old discussion (ish) on low humidity


With double blind, empirical result.
 
Last edited:
Since the humidity in my mouth is always 100%, the effect is zero. But when it’s very hot and dry, I do have to wet the reed more frequently while playing. On 100 deg F days on outdoor gigs, I use @turf3 ’s trick of a wet paper tower stuffed into my mouthpiece cap. Works great. I store my reeds dry, so no effect there either.
 
Not much as far as I'm concerned. I've had the sax in plenty cold (alps during the ski season, ships in the arctic) and hot (Greece in the summer, Caribbean), wet (well I live in England.....) and dry (again, Greece in the summer) conditions and never had much of an issue with them. Same care routine, wet the reed with my mouth before playing, stick on mouthpiece, if it's warped play for ten minutes and some more moistened and they usually return to shape. Wipe it and pop it in a reed box after playing. The end.
 
When I moved from sea level to the mountains (6000 ft, or about 2km), it was difficult to play my reeds - they seemed too hard. After about a week, once I had become accustomed to the altitude, I was fine. Having lived in both dry and humid conditions, I found little difference in reed response. More soaking in dry weather, of course.

I’ve known oboists who have “winter reeds” and “summer reeds”, presumably because of humidity changes, but I just use the same old reeds all year.
 
More worryingly, wiki says the maximum temperature for growing Arundo donax is 30⁰C, which the south of France easily outstriped, although not, maybe, in the growing season? Yet?
Very worrying. It probably dies instantly when the temperature spikes.
 
I find that the climate in my mouth is near 100% humidity and 90F. Consistently.

Yes, sometimes ambient conditions will make the tip of a reed crinkle more or less when it dries, but that always flattens out in a minute or two anyway.

And then once I start playing the thing, it's 100% RH and 90F temp.

This is why all the "humidity packs" and voodoo about soaking reeds, not soaking them, putting them in environmental chambers to store, etc., etc., etc., doesn't mean a hill of beans.

Get the thing wet, play it. When done wipe off on pants or a paper napkin, shove it into the reedguard, go home.

The only thing is keeping reeds damp on doubles so they're ready to play instantly. Lydian alluded to a trick I have published before. When you get all the reeds on the doubles ready, go to the bar and get a glass of water and a couple paper napkins. Tear off a piece of napkin, wet it, shove it down in the mouthpiece cap, put cap on MP. Now you have your own little humidity controlled environment inside the cap, keeping the reed wet for that 12 bar passage in that one chart.

At the end of the night, take the cap, open end down, rap sharply on the floor. The little wad of wet napkin falls out, you dispose of it, and pack up as per normal (wipe reeds on pants, shove into holder, go home).
 
<pedantic mode ON>
Humidity is for gasses, like breath. I'm not sure any heathy person has 100% humid breath, relative or otherwise.
Solids which are as wet as possible are, well, wet ... Lots of adjectives can be used but "humidly wet"?
<pedantic mode OFF>
 
Last edited:
I guess I'm missing the point of the "clarification".

When you're playing a reed, it's inside your mouth, surrounded by the atmosphere there. I don't know the actual RH of the inside of a human mouth, but given that it's a closed volume all of whose surfaces are covered with liquid water, it's got to be awfully close to fully saturated i.e., 100% RH. The air you breathe into your mouth from your lungs is coming from another closed volume all of whose internal surfaces (and there's a lot of surface area) are covered with liquid water. That's how lungs WORK. The air inspired dissolves into the water coating the alveoli, then passes through the barrier between the alveoli into the capillaries of the lungs.

The point is that once you wet a reed, then put it inside the high humidity environment of your mouth, whatever it was experiencing an hour before in the ambient conditions in the case or in the room, has become irrelevant.
 
Again, 100% RH refers to gasses. A fully saturated reed is as wet as possible.
I did say I was being pedantic... ie I - and I'm sure everyone - knew what you meant.
That’s exactly what turf and I are saying. Take your 95% RH breath, pass it through your saliva coated mouth and over your completely saturated reed, that air is probably pretty close to 100% RH.

How else would you make the comparison between the level of RH using a humidity pack in your case and sticking a reed in your mouth?

You do realize you’re mansplaining RH to two engineers, right? If you want to have a real discussion, let’s talk about how the RH would vary with the pressure drop and temperature gradient through the tip of the mouthpiece. But that’s also moot because it’s still going to be higher than any humidity pack.
 
Last edited:
How else would you make the comparison between the level of RH using a humidity pack in your case and sticking a reed in your mouth?
The pack controls the humidity of the air. That controlls how wet or dry the reed gets.
You do realize you’re mansplaining RH to two engineers, right
Actually, I'm PhD in physics 'splaining. And if you want to talk about the relationship between wet reeds and humidity; vapor pressure is what you want.

Again, I was making a small - I thought fun,, apparently not - asside and actually did understand the point.
 
OK, so saturation vapor pressure of water at room temp is 17.5 Torr. That's not real descriptive when we're talking about just how humid the air inside your mouth is.
 
Once they are boxed, I haven't found humidity an issue. However, I have noticed how humidity affects tuning, especially in the band. But then I am at 4,300 ft. (1 311 m) elevation. (Been living at elevation for so long, forgot what sea level is like.)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom