Playing the saxophone Daily practice.

Yes I understand that, but don't understand how taking steps to learn it would hold you back.
I think somethings lost in translation. It's not the trying to learn that's holding me back, it's the lack of knowledge that's holding me back and I'm self conscious I need to really work on that.

With the two concerts the orchestra has recently had, with a couple of solo's what practice I had was spent mostly getting those sorted, as well as practice for my lessons, which are costing me money so I want to work at that. As a result the scales and 'theory' had taken a back step, so moving forward as my teacher, and other players are pointing out, or asking what should be fairly basic stuff, I'm relatively clueless - all my own making.

And if that's the case, all the more reason to learn scales that can help you not be tied to playing from sheet music
I'm concious of that, my teacher has told me as much, but as Thomsax says, and even my own teacher, it's not really the best use of my money and time with my teacher learning scales with him. Which I can do at home (with pointers from my teacher), I just need to spend some time concentrating on those, and get it to stick in my head.

practice (maj, min) scales, arpeggios
I've been working on Majors for months, and I can play them, but then if I was asked how many sharps in any I couldn't recall it instantly. Finally the relationship between Major & minor has dropped, and I'm starting to add pentatonics into the mix.


Back to original subject of the post, that lack of structure to my practice is the root cause, I'm guilty of playing away for an hour or so with no real goal, I've improved over the 12months, but with more structure I think I could make better progress.
 
I think somethings lost in translation. It's not the trying to learn that's holding me back,
Aha, that makes sense - it seemed you were saying the learning it was holding you back. Got it now.
I'm concious of that, my teacher has told me as much, but as Thomsax says, and even my own teacher, it's not really the best use of my money and time with my teacher learning scales with him.
Absolutely. Sounds like teacher has the right idea
 
I like what Jamie Anderson says on his "Get Your Sax Together" channel and enjoy his weekly free videos. Today's video is about daily practice and has some very good guidance.

View: https://youtu.be/LfKYAtaXpQA


Rhys
Yes, that is the way I should do it if it wasn't for that I have a wife, children, grandchildren, houses to take care of, garden that also need som care, few friends .... and also I try to take care of myself (hold the weight down and "eat better"). Lots of good tips in this video. Maybe I borrow some?

Thanks for posting.
 
Caught that this morning, and some good tips. Just having the time to do it.

This morning I've played through my major scales, arpeggios, and then pentatonic scales (which came surprisingly easily so i'll be checking I'm doing them right) on both Alto & Tenor without written notes.

A quick play through on piece from my workbook, that I'm enjoying, but the key change is catching me out and starting to frustrate me.
 
Caught that this morning, and some good tips. Just having the time to do it.

This morning I've played through my major scales, arpeggios, and then pentatonic scales (which came surprisingly easily so i'll be checking I'm doing them right) on both Alto & Tenor without written notes.

A quick play through on piece from my workbook, that I'm enjoying, but the key change is catching me out and starting to frustrate me.
Hi can you put a reminder on the score atvthe key change..i.e. highlightvthe notes in the key changevthat or # or b..
 
Jamie Anderson is certainly enthusiastic and entertaining. Most of what he promotes for practice is pretty good, and could help many to get on track. However there is one aspect that IMHO needs to be handled very judiciously. Transcribing can be a good exercise in hearing a groove, getting a feel of certain accents in music, and picking up "licks". However this is potentially also a long term failing. I know of players who are technically extremely advanced compared to me, however all that they can do is "ape" a known sax hero.

Spending a lot of time copying a player you like can be rewarding and satisfying the closer you get to their sound, yet it also is a pattern that can then become your way of playing. This may not matter if you have no ambition to be something other than a "tribute player", but certainly isn't what any of those greats are known for. They are great because they developed their own unique voice and way of playing. Channeling someone else excludes your potential to be a unique voice if you're continually just playing what your sax idol would have played.

IMHO a little bit of transcription goes a long way. Give yourself some time and credit by coming to music with your own personality and ideas. These can be incorporated as you play either written or improvised music with the latter giving you more opportunities. It's far too easy for transcription to be a stylistic crutch that cripples your potential.
 
IMHO the kind is scheduled Jamie Anderson maps out is great - not far off what I do, at least.
But there's a layer missing. Stuff like that material should be both challenging and achievable. Although these matta, if you will, issues of skill acquisition are widely researched and discussed, I found the Bill Hilton book to be a great resource focused on music learning.
 
I know of players who are technically extremely advanced compared to me, however all that they can do is "ape" a known sax hero.
Clarence Clemons made a huge impact when I heard him for the first time back in 1973. After that I've been trying to play with the same power, energy ..... . Even if I was 17 in 1973, I already knew that there will just be one Clarence Clemons. I think I have all known recordings he made. I also have unknown recordings .... . If you have a player, that you like, close to you you will develop something in the same direction. I still turn up the radio in the car or in the kitchen so I can CC better. I'm fine with just being able to play something in "The Big Man" style. No improvising, I play it as it was transcribed/written or by memory.
 
Clarence Clemons made a huge impact when I heard him for the first time back in 1973. After that I've been trying to play with the same power, energy ..... . Even if I was 17 in 1973, I already knew that there will just be one Clarence Clemons. I think I have all known recordings he made. I also have unknown recordings .... . If you have a player, that you like, close to you you will develop something in the same direction. I still turn up the radio in the car or in the kitchen so I can CC better. I'm fine with just being able to play something in "The Big Man" style. No improvising, I play it as it was transcribed/written or by memory.
It's all about knowing what you want. If your total focus is in sounding like another player, then you're following your dream. The advice given by Jamie Anderson, and many others is general and would be given to one and all, regardless of what their dreams may be. As said, if your dream is to be a unique voice and a pro, then transcribing should be approached very judiciously.

If your thought process is always "how would (name your hero) play this?" Then it's simply not your voice, just an approximation of your sax hero, and in most cases not as good. It's your life and your time. Use it to fulfill your dreams, and just make sure that you're not following a programme that inadvertently makes you into something you didn't intend.

Keep open ears, open eyes, open mind, and (IMHO) always question whether a particular programme is taking you where you want to go.
 
In my last lesson, we tried a duet, me sight reading. It was a disaster on my part, but learnt a lot from it.

My timing is pants, so this week's practice has mostly been without my sax, and counting & clapping to a metronome, signing a rhythm to a metronome.

The new piece I'm working on getting the timing & rhythm tight, rather than just playing through it.

It's surprisingly frustrating, it sounds so simple to clap every off beat, feel like a complete dunce :doh:
 
In my last lesson, we tried a duet, me sight reading. It was a disaster on my part, but learnt a lot from it.

My timing is pants, so this week's practice has mostly been without my sax, and counting & clapping to a metronome, signing a rhythm to a metronome.

The new piece I'm working on getting the timing & rhythm tight, rather than just playing through it.

It's surprisingly frustrating, it sounds so simple to clap every off beat, feel like a complete dunce :doh:
It's good that your teacher has you doing rhythm exercises. It's possibly the most important factor of making good music, and so often overlooked. Matching what a metronome does can unfortunately be more intellectual than physical, which isn't necessarily the best way to approach rhythm. Clapping, is OK, but dancing is probably best as it's your whole body needing to "feel" the rhythm and become part of it. Many recognize that African drumming is pretty amazing. I was fortunate to have a few sessions with a master Ghanaian drummer in a seminar. He told us that to become a drummer you first had to be a proficient dancer. Rhythm comes from the body, it's not intellectual, it's felt. It's a whole discipline unto itself that if practiced enough can become automatic. Why do good musicians tap their foot, or seem to move so much? That's their keeping the rhythm in their body. It frees your hands, feet, voice, etc. to express itself in giving sounds (musical notes) that are wrapped within the rhythm that you're no longer having to "think about".

This is going to sound/seem weird: Think about learning to drive. At first you needed to concentrate on how far you moved your hands on the wheel to make a turn, how hard you pressed the pedals and develop a whole set of motor skills that = moving an inanimate object safely as transport. Do you still need to think that way? NO! It's automatic and you can listen to music, talk (hopefully not text) and have your mind otherwise engaged. Rhythm is learned the same way, and you can use it without concentrating on it. If continually concentrating on it, you are continuing to act like a driver that doesn't let their motor skills and sub conscious take over that skill. Rhythm isn't eye to hand via reading, it's felt in the body.

Reading is a very important skill, yet it takes a very long time to develop what ultimately you should get from it...that the notes your see on the page you hear, so that you know how they work in the rhythm... it's heard and felt.

One of the most difficult exercises for a beginner is fluent reading where good rhythm is kept. Instead most practice doing "stop/start" playing putting the emphasis on the right note instead of the rhythm. That's "musical death" and a practice that can take years to eliminate. Don't even go there! Always keep the rhythm and try to keep going. A wrong note is gone in an instant and can be followed by a lot of right notes. A section/phrase or tune can be repeated to get the notes right. Continually stopping denies the rhythm and flow, which is the most basic tenet of music.
 
playing putting the emphasis on the right note instead of the rhythm.
Kind of where I am, I "can" play, I do with an orchestra and along with backing tracks, even blat out pieces from a books that kind of sounds musical, but it's probably not as written. With the orchestra I've others to cling on to.

I've had dance lessons, learning to jive for my wedding. My teacher suggested a few exercises with a metronome. I'm guilty of not using the metronome when practicing too.

Fwiw; online sax academy is developing rhythm Improvement course, based on takadimi, including clapping/ta-kaing on the offbeat exercises, tough but, I found, beneficial.
I'll take a look, it's the off beats they are driving me mad.

I can see the benefit in working on it, so perseverance is the key.
 
'
I'll take a look, it's the off beats they are driving me mad.

I can see the benefit in working on it, so perseverance is the key.
I have my TE Tuner education mode set to ramp up from 100bps to 150, +4 every 8 bars or so, and the subdivision with 8th note rest / 8th bet... Then clap On the beat and say "di" on the offbeat... Till it all folds up... 10 mins or ao a day. It's horrible.
 
Oh I need to find the educational mode in TE :thumb:
Touch the metro tab twice to go to Advanced.
Then under the little robot icon you have various options including ramping up BPM
The 1-2-3-4 button will provide a count in, on the beat, each time the tempo increases
And the Subdivision (top right) will move the click off-beat.

Screenshot_20230804_111747_com.sonosaurus.tonalenergytuner.jpg
 
Last edited:
Kind of where I am, I "can" play, I do with an orchestra and along with backing tracks, even blat out pieces from a books that kind of sounds musical, but it's probably not as written. With the orchestra I've others to cling on to.

I've had dance lessons, learning to jive for my wedding. My teacher suggested a few exercises with a metronome. I'm guilty of not using the metronome when practicing too.

Sometimes answers given (mine and others) are not necessarily specifically for your benefit, but general as others (obviously) read these and may find information that could assist them. In other words, it's not always necessary to answer or affirm that you are already capable, aware, etc. It's just information being shared... it's there for anyone who might find it a step towards a direction that can help.

We're all on some sort of musical journey and generally don't know where an OP or others are at in their journey. We help if we can using whatever experiences we have. Do you know, or care to know my musical background? Do I have a over 60 years of experience or am I at the same juncture as you? Does it matter if the information given can help someone?
 
Touch the metro tab twice to go to Advanced.
Then under the little robot icon you have various options including ramping up BPM
The 1-2-3-4 button will provide a count in, on the beat, each time the tempo increases
And the Subdivision (top right) will move the click off-beat.

View attachment 23521
Awesome found it, that'll keep me amused.

Sometimes answers given (mine and others) are not necessarily specifically for your benefit, but general as others (obviously) read these and may find information that could assist them. In other words, it's not always necessary to answer or affirm that you are already capable, aware, etc. It's just information being shared... it's there for anyone who might find it a step towards a direction that can help.

We're all on some sort of musical journey and generally don't know where an OP or others are at in their journey. We help if we can using whatever experiences we have. Do you know, or care to know my musical background? Do I have a over 60 years of experience or am I at the same juncture as you? Does it matter if the information given can help someone?
I appreciate that, just replying and agreeing with your points. Your reply resonated and is almost word for word what my teacher is saying.

I was trying to highlight what I found surprising. The false perception of timing & rhythm I had. For me playing with others or backing tracks is OK. Playing to a metronome, is a real challenge. Affirming your "stop/start" comment is entirely correct.
 
Last edited:
Awesome found it, that'll keep me amused.


I appreciate that, just replying and agreeing with your points. Your reply resonated and is almost word for word what my teacher is saying.

I was trying to highlight what I found surprising. The false perception of timing & rhythm I had. For me playing with others or backing tracks is OK. Playing to a metronome, is a real challenge. Affirming your "stop/start" comment is entirely correct.
OK, guess you've got me in pedantic mode... To be very specific and expand on "metronome" ... it's not the same as developing an internal body felt rhythm. It's an external device that one depends on to give rhythm. What happens when there is no "tick"? Clapping, dancing rhythmic movement, and tapping your foot are all internal. If you feel that you can't initiate a rhythm think back to a song or piece of music you like. Sing it, dance it, etc. Another exercise is to listen to a track, then immediately after use your body to express that rhythm.

The metronome is a separate practice that has to do with consistency of the beat and almost nothing to do with feeling or groove. It's good for beginners who may have a problem with coordination in enforcing the fingers to make it to the next note on time. Beyond that...

Anyone can play with a click track (metronome heard in headphones for recording purposes) and have timing that doesn't vary. It externally enforces you to keep up or slow down. Feeling the beat/groove and internalizing it is ultimately what can separate an amateur sounding player from someone who can entertain. Audiences can't tell whether you've sped up or slowed down over the length of a track and it doesn't matter as much as communicating a groove or feel. The music of a master like Chopin emphasized that emotion can come from NOT playing like you're following a metronome. The best singers don't sing like they are strictly following a beat. They work against it by speeding up or stretching notes and often dragging the other musicians along (ritardando or accelerando).

That's probably more than enough from me as many would have opinions about click tracks that are obviously different to mine.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom