Beginner Saxes buying my first alto sax

I have a Theo Wanne Water ART which is very small and would also be suitable for a new learner. But again this may not suit you.

 
I have a Theo Wanne Water ART which is very small and would also be suitable for a new learner. But again this may not suit you.

it looks interesting,reputable brand ,not expensive and looks like the beak is rather slim.Thanks.
 
It's usual to stick with a beginners mouthpiece until you develop your embouchure and breath control. a 4C has a much narrower tip opening then a lot of mouthpieces so that they are easier to blow for beginners.
If you find the top uncomfortable you need to make sure you have other factors right, like the sling height so that the mouthpiece is in your mouth at the right angle. You may have to adjust the way you are playing rather than trying to fix things by buying different stuff.
That said, a decent mouthpiece is a good choice. Stock mouthpieces tend to be cheap and a bit inconsistant. Some will work OK - others might not.
The basic measurement of a mouthpiece is about the tip opening. Other measurements often arent' given, but things like the lay or chamber size or baffle can be mentioned with some brands. The outside isn't mentioned much but you do get some variation. It isn't necessarily the diameter that makes it more or less comfortable.
A mouthpiece patch can make a lot of difference. Try one of those before splashing out a lot of money on a new mouthpiece.
 
As Steve says... I think we could all suggest a favourite mouthpiece but you'd just end up with dozens of them and a bill for a few thousand pounds.

Your sax teacher may the best resource you have. If he/she is a good one they will have a dozen or so mouthpieces for you to examine and possibly try out.

Ask your teacher if they could spend a whole lesson discussing mouthpieces. It will be worth it if it's bothering you so much you can't progress past it.
 
As Steve says... I think we could all suggest a favourite mouthpiece but you'd just end up with dozens of them and a bill for a few thousand pounds.

Your sax teacher may the best resource you have. If he/she is a good one they will have a dozen or so mouthpieces for you to examine and possibly try out.

Ask your teacher if they could spend a whole lesson discussing mouthpieces. It will be worth it if it's bothering you so much you can't progress past it.
my teacher who is a a man,a professional sax player as well as teacher,,seemed perplexed when i told him the Yamaha bothers me as he was one of those who suggested it.I told him ill try at home and seewhat happens.I did try again both mouthpieces at home and thankfuly the stock one works for me.I did the basic scales that i was tought pretty easily with what sounded to my ears decent tone.The yamaha is almost impossible to play .I practicaly cant do anythng with it,so next lesson which is this saturday ill tell him i ll use the stock one from now on.I ll ask him about what he thinks about all this and see what he says.
 
The yamaha is almost impossible to play .I
That is very weird. You do need to try a selection of different reeds. And if you are trying it with a reed you have used on another mouthpiece, then in some case that can explain the issue. If the facing is very different then a reed can “form itself” to that mouthpiece and then not work well on another.

There is definitely something wrong though the Yamaha is impossible to play
 
Take the Yamaha MP to your teacher next lesson too as he may want you to demonstrate (again) the issues you're having with it and make suggestions.

Often my tutor would spot something I was doing wrong and suggest a change. It really helps to nip in the bud early on issues which could cause big problems later.

Let's say the Yamaha is very similar to every other MP and it's your Thomann that's weird. Getting used to it may preclude you from a bunch of professional MPs later on. It may be as simple as the amount of MP your have in your mouth; using a patch; or something simple he hasn't yet spotted, or as Pete says the reed, its position, the ligature, your neck strap, your shoes, the mittens you wear when playing... 😵
 
Take the Yamaha MP to your teacher next lesson too as he may want you to demonstrate (again) the issues you're having with it and make suggestions.

Often my tutor would spot something I was doing wrong and suggest a change. It really helps to nip in the bud early on issues which could cause big problems later.

Let's say the Yamaha is very similar to every other MP and it's your Thomann that's weird. Getting used to it may preclude you from a bunch of professional MPs later on. It may be as simple as the amount of MP your have in your mouth; using a patch; or something simple he hasn't yet spotted, or as Pete says the reed, its position, the ligature, your neck strap, your shoes, the mittens you wear when playing... 😵
thanks for trying to help,but im done withe yamaha.I put on the yamaha from day one because my teacher wanted me to and i was struggling.I tried the stock one at home and it works fine.THank god for that because i was getting really dissapointed about my struggling at the lessons.I ll just use the stock one form now on.The thing with the yamaha is very simple.Just when i put my mouth on it it feels weird right on.Without even blowing.Then when i blow i just cant control my tone AT ALL,my teacher told me i need a harder reed so he removed the 1.5 and put on a number 2.The it was worse,i had to struggele even worse.I told him it just doesnt work.Im not going through that again when i play the stock one with a1.5 reed very comfortably and easily.
 
One thing that comes to mind is the Yamaha definitely a 4C and not a wider tip opening like a 7C. Also is it new and genuine - can you return it as faulty?

Hard to make a judgement without seeing, but from your description I'd be going softer rather than harder on the reed.
 
One thing that comes to mind is the Yamaha definitely a 4C and not a wider tip opening like a 7C. Also is it new and genuine - can you return it as faulty?

Hard to make a judgement without seeing, but from your description I'd be going softer rather than harder on the reed.
i bought the yamaha 4c along with the sax from Thomann because many people told me that i need to use the Yamaha as a beginner,,i doubt there is anything wrong with it.At this point in time its useless to me but i may have use for it at some point in the future,i cant know that.
 
If you have it in your mind that the Yamaha will not work, then you are probably right. Not that the Yamaha is a bad piece, but it may be a bad match for you. It is a good lesson to remember in the instance that you start buying more mouthpieces based on other people's experiences and preferences.

On the other hand, as you gain experience, you will find that more and more mouthpieces and reeds will work quite well. With a well-developed air stream and support, an experienced player may even find it easy to blow through leaks that would leave a beginner squawking.

Get something that works for you now and stick with it.

Enjoy the path.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom