Blues Question

alan_

Member
Messages
72
Location
Laos
I know there is a really obvious answer to this question, but I am a little confused.

In a book called "Progressive Rock Saxophone" Peter Gelling writes

"The Dominant 7th chord, combined with the use of the minor 3rd is the real heart of Blues harmony."

Now if you play a Dominant 7th chord with a minor 3rd - isn\t that a minor 7th where you use the Dorian. So instead of

E7-E7-E7-E7
A7-A7-E7-E7
B7-A7-E7-B7

why wouldn't you play

Em7-Em7-Em7-Em7
Am7-Am7-Em7-Em7
Bm7-Am7-Em7-Bm7

Puzzled,
Alan
 
I think he probably means playing the minor 3rd along with the dominant 7th. So you have the major 3rd in the chord but with the minor 3rd played or sung against it.

If it's on the same instrument as part of the chord, the minor 3rd is usually an octave higher, in which case that chord is called a b10 or #9

E G# B D G
 
Yes, of course. In the example piece he alternates between the two. All is clear, I knew there was a simple explanation.
Thanks alot Pete.
 
So for a 'harder' explanation try this:

the minor 3rd note sounds good because of the tritone sound of the major 3rd and the minor 7th in the harmony:

eg E7 - major 3rd is G#, minor 7th is D (G# to D is a tritone or flat 5 interval)

if you play these two notes together on the piano with your left hand and then with your right hand play your minor 3rd note (G), that's the blues sound these notes produce

next try the A7 - major 3rd is C#, minor 7th is G and play the minor 3rd (C) - same story

finally B7 (the real 'away' chord comin home) - major 3rd is D#, minor 7th is A and play the minor 3rd (D) - bingo

this sort of exercise at a keyboard really helps you to hear blues changes, and this tritone interval (G#-D, C#-G and D#-A) is handy to know n hear - it's the tension that drives the blues!

Your question about why not use minor chords - try the same exercise but this time you'd be playing (G-D, C-G and D-A) - all perfect fifth intervals... and listen for the crunch. What? No crunch? That's the bland nature of those perfect 5th intervals...

Hope this helps (someone) ?!
Simon
 
It's helped me thanks Simon: Not so much because I didn't 'know' it, just that it's very useful to have these things broken down into the simple building blocks and explained with such clarity, even if as you move on things get more complicated, rules get blurred and broken etc.
 
Yeah - that is an excellent explaination. I will try out exactly what you suggest. I must get hold of a keyboard.

Sorry for the slow reply - internet down here for a few days. Cheers - Alan
 
Quick remark that "may" be of interest. As with most musical terms, the word dominant comes from the latin and has nothing to do with dominance but means "leading" and a dominant seventh chord wants to lead somewhere. In the so-called western harmony that is (not necessarily but) usually the fourth above. i.e. G7 - C
 
And to add to what Spike said, the "leading" is done by each of the individual notes of a chord acting a s a melodic line by itself.

A great way to get a feel for this is to play just 2 notes from this chord (the most important notes in fact) which are F and B.

You don't have to be a pianist to do this. Just Play these 2 notes on a keyboard and feel the tension.

Now move the F down to E and the B up to C. You will hear how the tension of the F against B (called a tritone as it's made up of 3 whole tones) is resolved into the "home chord" of C and E as these two "voices" lead to the next chord. (This is called voice leading)

This is slightly simplified as a G7 chord also has a G (obviously) and a D, and the C chord also has a G, but this is an example of how the really important tones lead melodically on to what's next.
 
Hi Pete...

yeah I think this is what I was tryin to say, but in the key of E

Simon

Pete Thomas wrote:
And to add to what Spike said, the "leading" is done by each of the individual notes of a chord acting a s a melodic line by itself.

A great way to get a feel for this is to play just 2 notes from this chord (the most important notes in fact) which are F and B.

You don't have to be a pianist to do this. Just Play these 2 notes on a keyboard and feel the tension.

Now move the F down to E and the B up to C. You will hear how the tension of the F against B (called a tritone as it's made up of 3 whole tones) is resolved into the "home chord" of C and E as these two "voices" lead to the next chord. (This is called voice leading)

This is slightly simplified as a G7 chord also has a G (obviously) and a D, and the C chord also has a G, but this is an example of how the really important tones lead melodically on to what's next.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,307
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom