old git
Tremendous Bore
- Messages
- 4,008
Pete and Kev,
Not sure if this is the correct place for this but felt uncomfortable extending the other thread.
A lot of thoughts and information in the other thread but this is the thoughts of someone who was playing blues on a tenor recorder over 54 years ago and shortly after trombone with a trad band. One of the phrases used by Morgan was "more sophisticated" and that triggered this response. It seems that a Bird solo would fit nicely over the "Matchbox" real R & B backing track with Jerry Lee Lewis rattling the joanna. That takes some backing up but something that happened when I was talking about keyboard backing to a classical violinist. Mentioned that playing a four note C, C E G C and changing to a C F A C gave a rocking beat when the violinist said, "That is an FMaj inversion." I am sure that Pete can describe it as a C4 something or other but it does suggest that the same chord can be named as having differing names according to what you choose to be the root note.
Got out Band in a Box this morning and sorted out C Jam Blues from a previous CaSLM Nosh 'n' Blow and you can't get simpler than that. My vibes lead on it would have made Bags jealous but you need a melody to be able to use BiaB's Re-harmonize (Canadian spelling) facility. Used the original very simple 7th structure and re-harmonised twice.
Here are the first four bars with the reharmonised versions underneath:-
Original C7 / / / , C7 / / / , C7 / / / , C7 / / /
First C2 / / / , Am7/ / / , C2 / / / , C2 / / /
Second CMaj7/Am7 / , Gm7/ C7 / , FMaj7/Fm6 / , C2 /C7sus/
In the remaining eight bars, Dm7, Em7, G7sus, CMaj9 and G13 appear.
This raises the question that if a machine, Apple Mac and BiaB can do this, is it sophisticated? More important, does it matter? Just as Parker could solo over an R & B backing, Jerry would have been just as happy rattling the ivories over any bebop rhythm section. And that reminds me of a discussion taking place on an Irish Traditional Music forum (don't ask)🙂 regarding blues. The Australian contingent were convinced that you cannot play "Blue Monk" against a simple blues tonic, sub dominant, dominant chord sequence and that if you did, you did not understand. As Sir John Whitmore has been a personal hero since his tyre shredding performance as a works Cooper Mini driver and his subsequent career as a coach, "did not understand" really means that the teacher does not have the ability to explain convincingly, which is what coaching is about.
Over to you experts, can a chord have many different names depending on which you nominate as a root note? If so, what defines a sophisticated blues chord sequence and has BiaB this capability? Only ask as one of those 'partly-trained-on-theory-musicians-who-seems-to-be-a-jack-of-all-trades-but-master-of-none'.
Not sure if this is the correct place for this but felt uncomfortable extending the other thread.
A lot of thoughts and information in the other thread but this is the thoughts of someone who was playing blues on a tenor recorder over 54 years ago and shortly after trombone with a trad band. One of the phrases used by Morgan was "more sophisticated" and that triggered this response. It seems that a Bird solo would fit nicely over the "Matchbox" real R & B backing track with Jerry Lee Lewis rattling the joanna. That takes some backing up but something that happened when I was talking about keyboard backing to a classical violinist. Mentioned that playing a four note C, C E G C and changing to a C F A C gave a rocking beat when the violinist said, "That is an FMaj inversion." I am sure that Pete can describe it as a C4 something or other but it does suggest that the same chord can be named as having differing names according to what you choose to be the root note.
Got out Band in a Box this morning and sorted out C Jam Blues from a previous CaSLM Nosh 'n' Blow and you can't get simpler than that. My vibes lead on it would have made Bags jealous but you need a melody to be able to use BiaB's Re-harmonize (Canadian spelling) facility. Used the original very simple 7th structure and re-harmonised twice.
Here are the first four bars with the reharmonised versions underneath:-
Original C7 / / / , C7 / / / , C7 / / / , C7 / / /
First C2 / / / , Am7/ / / , C2 / / / , C2 / / /
Second CMaj7/Am7 / , Gm7/ C7 / , FMaj7/Fm6 / , C2 /C7sus/
In the remaining eight bars, Dm7, Em7, G7sus, CMaj9 and G13 appear.
This raises the question that if a machine, Apple Mac and BiaB can do this, is it sophisticated? More important, does it matter? Just as Parker could solo over an R & B backing, Jerry would have been just as happy rattling the ivories over any bebop rhythm section. And that reminds me of a discussion taking place on an Irish Traditional Music forum (don't ask)🙂 regarding blues. The Australian contingent were convinced that you cannot play "Blue Monk" against a simple blues tonic, sub dominant, dominant chord sequence and that if you did, you did not understand. As Sir John Whitmore has been a personal hero since his tyre shredding performance as a works Cooper Mini driver and his subsequent career as a coach, "did not understand" really means that the teacher does not have the ability to explain convincingly, which is what coaching is about.
Over to you experts, can a chord have many different names depending on which you nominate as a root note? If so, what defines a sophisticated blues chord sequence and has BiaB this capability? Only ask as one of those 'partly-trained-on-theory-musicians-who-seems-to-be-a-jack-of-all-trades-but-master-of-none'.

