Bobby G
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 4,636
- Location
- Wonderful Welwyn Garden City, Herts
I've noticed several phrases that end on the 6th of the major scale on the tonic chord. All well and good, an A in the key of C major is fine, it's one of the notes in the major scale.
I've also noticed a similar thing in the minor key - in A minor, an F# seems perfectly acceptable (I'm thinking here of Miles' playing on Autumn Leaves on the Somethin' Else album by Cannonball) at the end of a phrase, much more so than an F natural.
Why should this be? F# doesn't occur in the major scale related to A minor, namely C, it's the b5, and yet it sounds right.
Remember I am self-taught but with a residual knowledge (and continuing interest) of theory from childhood paino lessons, filtered through many years of guitar-picking and bass-playing.
Am I making the mistake of equating a minor key to its relative major? Does this F# come from another scale or (ducks to avoid flak) mode? Am I trying to run before I can walk with the theory? Should I just accept the F# for now?
Cheers, Bob
I've also noticed a similar thing in the minor key - in A minor, an F# seems perfectly acceptable (I'm thinking here of Miles' playing on Autumn Leaves on the Somethin' Else album by Cannonball) at the end of a phrase, much more so than an F natural.
Why should this be? F# doesn't occur in the major scale related to A minor, namely C, it's the b5, and yet it sounds right.
Remember I am self-taught but with a residual knowledge (and continuing interest) of theory from childhood paino lessons, filtered through many years of guitar-picking and bass-playing.
Am I making the mistake of equating a minor key to its relative major? Does this F# come from another scale or (ducks to avoid flak) mode? Am I trying to run before I can walk with the theory? Should I just accept the F# for now?
Cheers, Bob
