I once worked for a man who made a complete replacement lock for an antique 1700's era flint musket, using nothing but a hacksaw, a hand "egg-beater" drill, a flat file, a round file and a triangular file. (He even filed the screw threads with the triangular file, and by hardening the screw, used it to cut the threads into the lock.) But that isn't saying that just anyone could. The same goes for instruments. A great musician can make just about any piece of garbage sound good, but we mere mortals need all the help we can get.
That said, I have to admit having traded an excellent mid 1960's Mark VI alto even-up for a cigar cutter, because I could not deal with the left pinky spatula system on the Mark VI. I tried for five years to get used to that axe and never DID feel comfortable with it. I was never certain when I went for a C#, B, or Bb, what I was going to get, unless I had time to think about it. I am still, ten years later, playing on the cigar cutter, and loving it.
For about twenty years, I had an extended loan of a 1941 Conn 12M from the local college, and loved it dearly. Give me a vintage horn every time. I used to worry when driving home from gigs about what I would do if someone rear-ended me, and wiped out my 1929 New Large Bore tenor. I have it insured for enough to buy a brand new Selmer, but probably couldn't play on one. So when I got a chance to buy a Modele 26, I jumped on it, just to have a spare that I could play on.