Help me analyze "Stella"

Throckmorten

Member
Messages
55
Location
Central NY, USA
I'm doing OK puzzling out how most of this song works.
One thing has me stumped

From the RealBook, Key=Bb

E-7b5, A7b9, C-7, F7
F-7, Bb7, Ebmaj7, Ab7
Bbmaj7, E-7b5/A7b9, D-7, Bb-7/Eb7


That Ab7 in the 8th measure, what is its function there? What allows him to slip that in?
 
Hey Throck

The short version: Stella's first 8 are just an elongated Idim -> I, in this case Bbdim7 -> Bbmaj7. Ab7 is a sub for a ivm chord (Ebm) which leads to I (Bb).

The long version... here goes:

When I first learnt this tune I reckoned the chords were wrong - Emi7b5/A7 which should go to Dm or D right? Instead it goes to a Cmi7. Then the Ab7 which would normally resolve to a Dbm or Db... instead goes to a Bbmaj7? What's that about?

If you take a look at the original changes, the first chord is really a Bbdim7 chord which can also be thought of as Dbdim7/Bb. It is a common device to begin songs with Idim to Imaj7. For example "Star Eyes" is often played that way.

The reason why I think of it as Dbdim7/Bb is cos of the smooth move to Cmin7 chord. This is a common move, iiibdim7 going to iim7 as in the beginning of "Embraceable You".

So how do we get from Dbdim7/Bb to Emi7b5? Well Dbdim7 is the same as Edim7. Someone a long time back just tried substituting Emi7b5 for Edim7 in this case since they only differ by one note.

Next, you can always try a V after a mi7 or mi7b5 and in this case it works. So really the A7 chord is just a kind of color chord that doesnt really have any real impact on the harmonic movement.

In fact despite all this, the Emi7b7 to A7 still functions as a Dbdim7 chord which naturally can move to Cmi7, which is the next chord.

Then there's this Ebmaj7 -> Ab7 -> Bbmaj7. I think of the Ab7 chord as an Ebm6/Ab . So what we really have is a plagal cadence (iv-i). So it's actually Eb -> Ebm -> Bb (IV, ivm to I). The Eb is from a major plagal cadence and Ebm from a minor plagal cadence.

The reason why this is important to know is that the 'scale de choice' so to speak would be an Eb melodic minor scale . The point here is realize is that the available tension tones would be 9, #11, 13. Many people try other approaches to the dominant chord here and they don't work at all. Similarly for chordal instruments, the chord becomes Ab13#11.

So in summary, I see the first 8 bars of stella as kind of a long version of idim7 to I (Bbdim7 to Bb)... it sure is a long way, gettin there's half the fun? 😉

Simon
 
Thank you Simon!

I was just breaking this down into a series of ii-V's and the best I could figure was some kind of common tone modulation. It sort of works but clearly wasn't hitting it right.

Harmonizing diminished chords is still out there for me. I'll have to print out your response and read it slowly over a cup of coffee.

Thanks again.

John
 
Sorry - that bit about Ab7 being a 'sub' for Ebm isn't really right. I should mean it's the V7 following the iim (as in Ebm7->Ab7) cos it's the dominant, right?
Simon
 
simon wrote:
Sorry - that bit about A7 being a 'sub' for Ebm isn't really right. I should mean it's the V7 following the iim (as in Ebm7->Ab7) cos it's the dominant, right?
Simon


Refering to the first to bars where the A7 functions as the dom and implying a D (or Dm) with the E-7b5.
Yes.
Thanks again.
 
Simon is correct, butanother way to look at it is modal interchange - a neat way to explain or analyase many substitute chords.

Often the bVII is substituted for the V7 - you can think of it as "borrowed" from the aeoiian mode.

The aeolian of Bb goes Bb C Db Eb F Gb Ab Bb so you can see it contains an Ab7. It's basically being in the key of Bb major, but just for that bar you imagine you are in Bb minor (aeolian).
 
By the way regarding Ab7 In Bb major or indeed bVII7 in any major key.
In addition to the explanation given that it is borrowed from the parallel key, here is another legitimation:

Bbmajors parallel is Gminor, the dominant in Gminor is D7, and the tritone-sub for D7 is Ab7

In "Stella By Starlight" instead of resolving on the minor-tonic, it resolves on the parallel ie. Bbmaj7 (meassure9)
 
Travtorn Naglemarv wrote:
By the way regarding Ab7 In Bb major or indeed bVII7 in any major key.
In addition to the explanation given that it is borrowed from the parallel key, here is another legitimation:

Bbmajors parallel is Gminor, the dominant in Gminor is D7, and the tritone-sub for D7 is Ab7

Very interesting, but wouldn't that imply that D7 could also be used to resolve to Bb maj7?
 
resolve might be a strong word for it, but since Bb^ and Gm9 can be substituted for each other in the right contexts, theres no reason a III7-I cadence wouldnt be usable (again in context)
 
First off all I absolutely agree that the parallel key is the most plausible explanation.

D7 & Ab7 or Ebm6 for that matter, resolves in nearly the same way on Bbmaj7,
The dissonance created between C & F#/Gb changes to consonance when F#/Gb becomes F-natural on Bbmaj7,

D7b9 contains all the notes which are important in F7

Lets take a look:
F A C Eb
D F# A C Eb

Actually "Stella By Starlight" makes use of the same harmonic change in meassure 12 - 13: / Bbm7 Eb7 / Fmaj7 /

Greetings from Travtorn
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,305
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom