Clarinet The old licorice stick

Which is all fine unless you are a CMN (Complete Miller Nerd). There were one or two of those when I was at college.
This I can understand your point of view. Basically they can't see the forest for the trees. But once they left college, which tends to be an artificial environment, wonder if they still had that opinion once they saw the necessity to put food on the table.

We had a few like that in the military bands. But interestingly enough, those that seemed to complain the most (sometimes on the most trivial of issues) were the very ones to renew their contracts to stay in.
 
Isn't it true sometimes that a band given its limited instrumentation, to please an audience, will run with the essence of Glenn Miller instead of an exact replication of Glenn Miller's sound?
I'm no GMN, but there is a limit to how much reductionism can be applied and still retain the essence. Sometimes it's appropriate to say "We cannot perform that piece as intended."
 
Which is all fine unless you are a CMN (Complete Miller Nerd).
I just wanted to add, for example, I found this arrangement for sale of the well known Glenn Miller recorded classic, In the Mood.


It has an audio sample that was recorded by Doc Severinsen's band. It is well done, it is good, I like the sound, but it is not 100% Glenn Miller. It is more like modern jazz style, solos are different, but one still recognises that it is the tune.

Here is a little history on it:

Personally I feel that one just goes with what they got. If it is a little 9 piece combo, perhaps even smaller, people except perhaps for that rare minority Miller Nerd will appreciate it.
 
I just wanted to add, for example, I found this arrangement for sale of the well known Glenn Miller recorded classic, In the Mood.


It has an audio sample that was recorded by Doc Severinsen's band. It is well done, it is good, I like the sound, but it is not 100% Glenn Miller. It is more like modern jazz style, solos are different, but one still recognises that it is the tune.

Here is a little history on it:

Personally I feel that one just goes with what they got. If it is a little 9 piece combo, perhaps even smaller, people except perhaps for that rare minority Miller Nerd will appreciate it.
“In the Mood” was not originally scored with clarinet.

Once you’re played the original score with full band, you’ll never accept anything less.

View: https://youtu.be/aME0qvhZ37o?si=fYBpMYugfOjBqJzX
 
Here is a very detailed history of this tune. Written and originally arranged by Joe Garland, it underwent many changes over the years. https://www.loc.gov/static/programs...ervation-board/documents/InTheMood_Spragg.pdf

I agree that the original Glenn Miller arrangement is excellent, but like much music, I grew tired of it due to repetition, and the requirement it be played on almost every commercial gig I worked in the 1970s. Even in a trio (piano, bass, sax). Gag me with a spoon. We used to call it “In The Nood”…
 
I agree that the original Glenn Miller arrangement is excellent, but like much music, I grew tired of it due to repetition, and the requirement it be played on almost every commercial gig I worked in the 1970s. Even in a trio (piano, bass, sax). Gag me with a spoon. We used to call it “In The Nood”…
Thanks for the Library of Congress link on In the Mood's history. I downloaded it and read it. "In the Nude", I love it. 😉

In the mid 1970's before heading to college, it was still popular. A requirement came down from our HQ of our 25th Infantry Division Band to play a field version of In the Mood. Short tasking, our trombonist, Bob, who was also our arranger, was going to spend a couple days hand arranging parts for us. Whilst assisting the band's librarian, I found we already had a folder on file with all parts, which spared him the task. It was a marching band version.

(We still had music in boxes, as the band received the music library of the recently deactivated 264th Army Band, Honolulu. Roughly 15 of us didn't receive transfer orders to other bands were transferred to the 25th at Schofield Barracks in Wahiawa, Oahu, Hawaii.)

We ended up playing it a good number of times in various venues we did, military school graduations (various job related short duration courses (2 weeks to say a month or 2, classes held on the base like Non-Commissioned Officer's Leadership Course, civilian world they are called work related continuing education courses), pass in review ceremonies during in-place music, sports pep-band events,etc.

Someone on top loved that song.

Moving on now as a reservist, back in the 1980's with the 300 AB in So Cal, we didn't do Miller stuff, but did a lot of Nestico (Hay Burner, Basie Straight Ahead, Switch in Time, etc.)

Summer 2 weeks, we'd spend one year in Sierra Vista near Tucson, AZ filling in for the 62nd AB on blanket leave (holiday), the other (alternated between the two) at Presidio, San Francisco (Army base at south end of the Bay Bridge) filling in for its band (don't remember the designation - since, base now closed).

Many of our members were prior active service bandsmen. When top brass was coming to visit us, one of the trombone players, Bob, used to refer to the colonels (rank was a symbolic eagle) as the "man with the chicken on his collar". (Doesn't seem in nearly every band, we have a trombonist named "Bob"?) 😉
 
Shake it baby!

The comic actor and 'Goon Show' star Peter Seller's requested that “In The Mood” was played at his funeral. This was a tune that the Goons hated being into 'trad jazz'.

Fellow Goons - Spike Milligan and Harry Secombe - were trying hard not to laugh and got stern looks and muttered comments from those not in the know. Having the last laugh :rofl:

1753459202153.webp
 
Being a very fine clarinet player, and being famous/well known, to the general population, is mostly about hit tunes, played or composed.
Acker, was no Stranger to that.
DeFranco, has a long list of tunes.

The first time I heard Paquito D'Rivera, play Alto Sax, I turned to the Mrs, and said, I bet he is a fine Clarinet player.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_VfDtZLxtI
 
Being a very fine clarinet player, and being famous/well known, to the general population, is mostly about hit tunes, played or composed.
Acker, was no Stranger to that.
DeFranco, has a long list of tunes.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_VfDtZLxtI
Did you know that Acker Bilk made a big band album with Stan Tracey? It’s quite a surprising mix, and one might think that he’d get shown up, be he plays great. Can’t remember the album name without Google
 

Popular Discussions on the Café

Forum statistics

Topics
27,316
Messages
505,790
Members
7,098
Latest member
welitmyguy
Back
Top Bottom