I didn't like any of them Even the Tubby Hayes one managed to sound cheesy (but not as much as the others).
I may not know much about music - but I know what I don't like - ;} and it seems to me some tunes just don't transfer well to the saxamophone.... personal preference I guess
What is it about Beatles songs? I can't see what all the fuss is about. Simple tunes with apt lyrics for the times. I put them in with the Sound of music and Abba. The tunes won't swing and they hardly rock and the best versions were covers by other bands. I do like to play the long and winding rd though and norwegian wood, and penny lane is fun and I used to play a reggae version of eleanor rigby..........come to think of it........I suppose they're modern folk songs.