Hope it’s ok to comment in such an old thread....,
As a beginner I sort of assumed that people that had been playing a while had the whole embouchure thing sussed and only newbs like me struggled
this thread has been most informative!
I got to a point where I was going to give up: I had tried going up a Reed strength ( from Rico 1.5 to Vandoren 2) and had caused my bottom lip so much hurt I decided this just was beyond me. Also I’d almost cut through the top mp guard( whatever the black stick on bitis called)
I had a rest while lip healed (and feeling decidedly depressed, sent back the hired YTS 280) but kept watching videos etc & noticed that not everyone had their bottom lip over the teeth as I’d been taught also someone pointed out that I didn’t HAVE TO increase Reed strength - I guess I had assumed it was mandatory!
in fact some seemed to have their bottom lip extended out quite a bit (one especially-was it dexter someone? Can’t remember)
I had already worked out that I could relax my embouchure for the deepest notes and still make helluva volume and that it helped having slightly more mp in the mouth
so this gave me hope again and I threw caution to the wind and bought a YTS 62, determined to learn to play (lockdown fever well and truly set in)
My favourite player at the moment is Ben Webster (especially love that concert with Oscar Peterson) - now I couldn’t see exactly how his embouchure was but it looked further out too ..so I thought it must be possible...
When I got the YTS 62 I decided to stick to 1.5 reeds and with some trepidation set to seeing if I could produce a sound, any sound, without crucifying my lip.
I more or less pouted and hardly let my top teeth touch the mp top and blew.....
Revelation! Not only could I make a decent sound through the notes I knew (down to F , I’m only as far as unit 3) but also the next three notes down came out easily and it sounded much better than it had when blowing the 280. ( not just me saying that, my wife said the tone was much nicer)
As I went up to higher notes I pulled my lips a little tighter and moved back a bit on the mp but still not to the point where it could be hurt by my teeth ( which are uneven, those that I still have)
I now do an hour and a bit in the morning, I do long tones until my lips give up, usually after 20 mins, and then try to play the pieces up to unit three and here’s the thing: with this new embouchure I CAN play the Vandoren strength 2 and a Rico strength 2.5, without any pain at all!
One thing I have noticed is when I get a really nice sound on each note I can feel and hear it in my mouth and so it feels like I’m singing it even though I’m not and this gets me to shape my tongue, mouth, throat, as if I was singing it and this makes it even easier to play it - is this a recognised thing or am I just weird? ( perfectly prepared to accept the latter)
So thank you for this great thread on embouchure it has been a great resource and great encouragement