support Tutorials CDs PPT mouthpieces

Charlie or Maceo?

Charlie or Maceo?

  • Charlie

    Votes: 2 22.2%
  • Maceo

    Votes: 7 77.8%

  • Total voters
... Musselwhite (referencing my second instrument here)... 's far as the main poll goes 50/50... though probably Maceo....
Maceo every time, out of these two. Never much cared for Charlie.
Overall Maceo at the moment! Although i play more charlie parker than maceo on the sax, i prefer to listen to maceo!
I find them both quite inconsistent. The best of both I absoluetly love and the worst of both makes me want to switch off or walk out.

Saw Maceo at a gig in Basingstoke and it was pretty inconsistent: great sax sound and funky, rhythmical playing but some of the hip-hop (?) numbers were extremely dull. There was a punch-up in the audience to liven things up ! I have the same reaction to some of Candy Dulfer's playing, with a few tunes droning on and on.

The worst of Charlie Parker I find his tone quite poor and his playing a bit mechanical, but maybe it's down to the drugs. The best of Brird is absolutely inspirational, with a gorgeous tone and endless ideas, superbly executed.

Maybe it would help to have some posts saying what favourite recordings people have of these two and any other Parkers.

Maceo, Maceo, many times can we vote in 24 hours? Can we use diffeent IP addresses? Can we use different browsers? Tee hee..only kidding ;}
Love Maceo in small doses but I feel the same way as Rhys about him live- saw him in Brighton- great sound, very funky but absolutely no dynamics over an hour and a half set... very odd, I don't think the BPM or intensity shifted at all for the duration (any 15 minutes were superb but it couldn't sustain interest without some 'light and shade'...
Dot was wittier than either.

Similar threads


John Talcott

We won't forget all your truly wonderful contributions. Your insight, skill, knowledge, support and humour made the Café a better place. Thank you jbtsax.

See some of John's contributions

Add your message for John and his family

New Posts


Top Bottom