Brass Brass Again.

O

O.C.V.

Member
113
North Lancs
It must be twelve years since I played a brass instrument, trumpet,cornet and tenor horn, mainly in brass bands but also some big band work and a little orchestral. I recently got a hankering to try it again so rescued my old cornet from my grandson. It took a little organising as he lives 200 miles away, but I got it yesterday. He hadn't used it for a couple of years so it needed valves cleaning and oiling and the slides freeing and greasing. Then I was ready to have a go. Oh dear, it was never as hard as this. It's going to take some time to get my embouchure back, if ever, but I'll persevere with long tones on harmonics to see if I make any progress. If anyone has any advice on keeping sax and cornet going together I'd be very grateful. Meanwhile back to the Charles Colin book.
Regards,
O.C.V.
 
Got a trumpet last week after 30 years. I know how you feel. My 4th line D is sooooo flat....
 
For what it is worth it is always better to start practising trumpet first and then play sax afterwards. Playing trumpet first will have a positive effect on your sax embouchure but it does not work the other way around. When I had same day lessons in both I would always have my trumpet lesson first. If you play sax to start and then try to get a decent sound out of a trumpet you may be a little disappointed!

Also the Jazz Method for Saxophone (John O'Neill) has a trumpet equivalent written by Steve Waterman - very good it is too!
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Jazz-Method-Trumpet-Tutor-Book/dp/0946535256
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is interesting for me as I've got a flugel horn languishing under my bed! I played tenor and flugel horn in brass bands all through my childhood and into my twenties, and often thought of restarting. I've only been playing sax for a few years, but it feels 'right', if you know what I mean. The last time I got the flugel out, I was shocked at how difficult it was to play it - lol, I suppose a few decades off can have that effect! :shocked:
 
Tom gave me this advice as have gone the other way played trumpet and added the sax, i also make sure i leave a good 3/4 hours after playing the sax before i pick up the trumpet again. good luck with it. ;}

TomMapfumo said:
For what it is worth it is always better to start practising trumpet first and then play sax afterwards. Playing trumpet first will have a positive effect on your sax embouchure but it does not work the other way around. When I had same day lessons in both I would always have my trumpet lesson first. If you play sax to start and then try to get a decent sound out of a trumpet you may be a little disappointed!

Also the Jazz Method for Saxophone (John O'Neill) has a trumpet equivalent written by Steve Waterman - very good it is too!
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Jazz-Method-Trumpet-Tutor-Book/dp/0946535256
Click to expand...
 
I've got a bass trombone on the way to me in the post. God help me. But I'm sure it's somewhat analogous to a baritone sax as a trumpet is to an alto - as per Tom's post above.
 
I went to see/hear Grimethorpe Colliery Band at the weekend and now have a hankering after a trombone. Chris Gomersall played a wonderful solo but I can't remember the piece!!
 
old git said:
Grab yourself some JJ Johnson, Kai Winding, Jimmy Cleveland, Juan Tizol and Bob Brookmeyer, Sue.
Click to expand...
Thanks - I've out them on my ever growing list of 'must listen to' before 21st December! I'm sure i've come across Bob Brookmeyer before - the name rings a bell or two.
 
Very nice Tom. Just listened to him and Stan Getz doing Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square on Spotify - beautiful. Now listening to The Blues Hot & Cold Remastered. I'm ignorant about trombones (other than liking the sound they make) and don't know what a valve trombone is. Off to do internet searching on different 'bones.
 
2 main tenor trombones:

1. Slide trombone - where notes are made by combination of embouchure and slide position
2. Valve trombone - notes made by combination of embouchure and valves - just like a trumpet - 3 buttons which lengthen the overall tube length.

People would think that valve trombones are easier as notes are made using valves of set length, but slide trombone is very easy really.
 
How much do you reckon taking up the slide trombone would confuse a beginner's sax embouchure? I assume it would develop the same muscles and awareness / control of the throat, tongue and larynx, helping with the sax as well.

How I got the idea was I saw a video demo of Yamaha's Silent Brass, and it really goes quiet as a whisper, that's definitely something I could play late at night. The slide trombone would probably train my ear quite a bit. And since my wife's starting with the cello, I could share her pain of always being out of tune. 🙂

Also, is getting a Bb/F trombone worth the extra price? Does it add more hassle and/or make it easier to break and/or more difficult to maintain? Or should a beginner not worry about the extension and just get a regular Bb trombone?


Cheers,
Jori
 
1. A slide trombone is a good instrument!
2. No problem with embouchure - I have played sax and trombone regularly on the same day. My usual advice is to play brass first and then leave a gap for embouchure to adjust for sax. The other way around is less adviseable as it is harder to immediately adjust to a tighter embouchure after playing sax - for both trombone and trumpet, which will be too loose for a while after playing sax.
3. Trombones can be used with mutes, especially practice mutes, which severely reduce volume produced, no problem.
4. I have 5 slide trombones and sold my only Bb/F trombone - more complicated and fine if using in an orchestral setting, but unsure whether they are worth the extra money.
5. John Packer/Rath trombones are quite superb - leave all others in their wake, like Vincent Bach, Yamaha and others.

Hope this helps
Tom
 
Hi Jori, I've been playing a bass trombone for 3 weeks now, and can report that it doesn't seem to cause any embouchure complications when I go back to the bari or the other reeds that I play. In fact, it's much less troublesome than doubling clarinet / sop sax and bari.

As for playing Bb / F trombone - that's up to you. My mission is to play bass trombone so I found an old Boosey Imperial single rotor bass - the cheapest way to do it - and am enjoying it greatly.
 
There can be a lot of positive transfer between tone production playing a brass instrument and playing the saxophone. Skills such as hearing the note before you play, setting the oral cavity (tongue position), and adjusting the airstream that are required to play a brass instrument also help to improve your saxophone playing.

In my circle of friends who were also school band teachers, the "trombone" was affectionately know as:

"a wind driven, manually operated, pitch approximator".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Café QuickLinks

Contact admin or mod
Timezones
Saxophone Glossary
Forum issues support
Calendar
Taming The Saxophone

Bluesky  Facebook

Members' Blogs

Calendar events

Latest: Members' Recordings

Trending content

Forum statistics

Topics
29,699
Messages
515,325
Members
8,759
Latest member
Jeff Dewey
Back
Top Bottom