- Messages
- 7,880
- Location
- Near Lutterworth, Leics.
Just tried all these out against each other using Buffet 400 Alto, MJ 2 1/2 reed and Buffet Crampon metal ligature.
The "El Cheapo" Windcraft is here: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/251158958064?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649
The Yam4C is my usual MP, so compared to it the others sounded...
1/ Esprit round chamber
Liked this, and probably the closest sound to the Yam4C which also has a slightly rounded chamber.
Easy blow with no real thought having to be put into playing it.
Tighter fit on neck cork than the Yam.
2/ Esprit II square chamber
Slightly more edgy than the round chamber standard Esprit. More resistance and slightly harder work. A few bum notes, not sure why as the opening looks the same as the standard Esprit? Must be me, or maybe needs a softer reed.
Tighter fit on neck cork than the Yam.
3/ Windcraft cheapie square chamber
Loud, fairly raucous, and less direct sound, by which I mean I had to control the pitch as it was liable to go off. Having said that it was very flexible once I knew what was going on. Could be fun. Easier blow than the two Esprits. This has a similar but smaller square chamber to the Esprit II.
For £6 posted with WHITE GLOVES, neck strap, polishing cloth and cork grease you may be tempted. I was more so as I happened to have a £5 eBay voucher to use.
Same fit on neck cork as the Yam.
I could spend hours changing reeds and ligatures (not sure the latter makes any difference) to change this first opinion. Currently I'd rate them:
1st Esprit
2nd Yam 4C (probably as I'm used to it).
3rd Esprit II
4th Windcraft cheapie
Anyone else compared the two Esprits against each other and any similarly priced MPs?