Saxophones AMETHYST - Martin Reiner Markneukirchen Tenor saxophone
- Thread starter ProfJames
- Start date
- Messages
- 21,947
Are you talking about this one?
http://www.ebay.de/itm/Antikes-Saxo...t=Antike_Musikinstrumente&hash=item565383356a
I don't recognise it, haven't heard of the maker. But it's a lot like the Akustics and Weltklangs and other saxes from there. Seems a bit overpriced to me, but there's and interesting extra key on the left just above the bell. Seller clearly knows nothing about saxes.
One thing I'm sure of - this has nothing to do with the US Martin saxes. Best guess is that Martin Reiner was a dealer, not a builder, but I could be wrong. If he was a builder, then most of the parts were probably bought in from other makers in the area.
http://www.ebay.de/itm/Antikes-Saxo...t=Antike_Musikinstrumente&hash=item565383356a
I don't recognise it, haven't heard of the maker. But it's a lot like the Akustics and Weltklangs and other saxes from there. Seems a bit overpriced to me, but there's and interesting extra key on the left just above the bell. Seller clearly knows nothing about saxes.
One thing I'm sure of - this has nothing to do with the US Martin saxes. Best guess is that Martin Reiner was a dealer, not a builder, but I could be wrong. If he was a builder, then most of the parts were probably bought in from other makers in the area.
- Messages
- 21,947
On ebay? Yes. Interesting way of assembling the sax... Too far for me to go and see it, I can't drive at the moment, anyway. I've sent the ebay link to Helen who runs bassic-sax and is researching/posting quite a lot about older German and Cz saxes. She might know more. The East Geman makers were all nationalised into what became VEB in Markneukirchen post WWII. Some good saxes, but with a caveat that you may find the keywork dated by modern standards. Nice vintage sound on most of them and built like tanks. I love my alto, which came from just over the border in Kraslice.
Sax seems a touch overpriced to me, maybe I'm missing something, though..
Sax seems a touch overpriced to me, maybe I'm missing something, though..
Colin the Bear
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 13,057
- Messages
- 21,947
PJ, think of it as a Weltklang. It's about 30-40% over priced for Germany, and probably double the best you could expect in the UK in playing condition.
- Messages
- 21,947
PJ, Sorry you must have missed what I said earlier. It is NOT a Martin stencil - at least not from the US Martin firm. There's also a French Martin company, completely disassociated with the US firm.
This is a bog standard post WWII East German sax. Apart from the unusal name on it, there's nothing to make one think it's in any way special. It doesn"t have full pearls, or an ornate finish for instance. You can't tell from the pics if it's got rolled tone holes or not, a desireable feature on these horns. The seller doesn't know what he's doing, there's no realistic statement on condition - pads/playability - and you don't even know if the neck will fit. That neck brace is a common feature on Weltklangs.
Martin Reiner is just a normal person's name. Could have been a shop, or a small maker assembling from mostly bought in parts. The sax industry there and across the border in Cz was a mix of factories, and small subcontrators/builders. Although this chaged with nationalisation after WWII, it wasn't overnight.
Buying a pre-war sax from that area pretty much guarantees high quality, good plating and (for the time) good playability. But standards slipped post war, and you've no way of assessing of this is a junker or a winner.
imho it's overpriced, even for Germany and you're taking a big risk if you do buy it..
This is a bog standard post WWII East German sax. Apart from the unusal name on it, there's nothing to make one think it's in any way special. It doesn"t have full pearls, or an ornate finish for instance. You can't tell from the pics if it's got rolled tone holes or not, a desireable feature on these horns. The seller doesn't know what he's doing, there's no realistic statement on condition - pads/playability - and you don't even know if the neck will fit. That neck brace is a common feature on Weltklangs.
Martin Reiner is just a normal person's name. Could have been a shop, or a small maker assembling from mostly bought in parts. The sax industry there and across the border in Cz was a mix of factories, and small subcontrators/builders. Although this chaged with nationalisation after WWII, it wasn't overnight.
Buying a pre-war sax from that area pretty much guarantees high quality, good plating and (for the time) good playability. But standards slipped post war, and you've no way of assessing of this is a junker or a winner.
imho it's overpriced, even for Germany and you're taking a big risk if you do buy it..
altissimo
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 3,354
You may also encounter Martin Busine and Martin Freres saxes - these have no connection with the US made Martin saxes - they're French. There may also be Robert Martin instruments - also French.
Stick to the american Martin saxes - I've got 3 and they're great... eventually I'll decide which one I want to keep and get rid of the other 2, but Martin junkie-dom is a hard habit to kick...
Stick to the american Martin saxes - I've got 3 and they're great... eventually I'll decide which one I want to keep and get rid of the other 2, but Martin junkie-dom is a hard habit to kick...
Colin the Bear
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 13,057
And a Bob Martin won't improve your playing but may give you a cold wet nose and a glossy coat.
thomsax
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 3,789
I second that. I have 6 Martins that I use and some other Martin made saxes. My oldest Martin is from -34. But I've been looking for a late Martin HC soprano. Great sopranos. Dark and round sound. I know were I can get one. And then there is The Martin Magna Baritone low A. In the same town. The problem is, they are asking too for the soprano and the bari. I've been trying to play a little more contemporary saxes, but the Martins are the #1 for me. I've never sold any Martin.
Thomas
- Messages
- 7,337
I'm afraid thomsax the diagnosis is one of extreme Martinophilia
The condition is potentially terminal unless you take the necessary steps of sending all your saxophones to me and I can quarantine them out of temptations way
TheSax.Info
New Member
- Messages
- 18
Howdy. Just came by because I was doing a bit of looking into Martin Reiner saxophones. Some info:
http://www.museum-markneukirchen.de/forum/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=8
http://saxwelt.de/index.php/geschichte/deutschland?showall=&start=1
I'll Google Translate then transliterate from the Museum Markneukirchen website:
While Reiner and some other makes under the Migma umbrella are not well known, a lot of them are really nice looking. I've also theorized that all the folks in the Migma group shared their designs, to some extent. Whether this = "great quality" or "no need for R&D" is up for debate.
http://www.museum-markneukirchen.de/forum/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=8
http://saxwelt.de/index.php/geschichte/deutschland?showall=&start=1
I'll Google Translate then transliterate from the Museum Markneukirchen website:
Looks like Reiner was part of the Migma collective. That was essentially a "clearing house" for professional quality (East) German and other Germanic makes and models. (They're still around, btw.)
While Reiner and some other makes under the Migma umbrella are not well known, a lot of them are really nice looking. I've also theorized that all the folks in the Migma group shared their designs, to some extent. Whether this = "great quality" or "no need for R&D" is up for debate.
